Showing posts with label The American Chess Quarterly. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The American Chess Quarterly. Show all posts

Tuesday, 3 October 2023

Refuting The King's Gambit IV

NOT withstanding his Bust of the King's Gambit in The American Chess Quarterly, Fischer had a surprise in store two years later when he faced Larry Evans, one of the driving forces behind the magazine.

Fischer - Evans
US Championship (New York) 1963
King's Gambit
1.e4 e5 2.f4!? exf4 3.Bc4!?
Fischer's choice of the Bishop's version of the King's Gambit over the much-more popular Knight's could hardly have been predicted by Evans, who responded with the principled:
3...Qh4+
The point of White's beginnerish-looking play is that after ...
4.Kf1
... White will gain time hitting the black queen.
4...d6 5.Nc3!?
According to Viktor Bologan in Bologan's Black Weapons In The Open Games (New In Chess 2014), "Fischer was not satisfied with this move, mostly because he was caught by surprise when Black answered with ..."
5...Be6
... which Bologan awards an exclamation mark.
Unfortunately Bologan does not explain how Fischer would have varied, and the latter's games in ChessBase's 2023 Mega database are no help as subsequent opponents did not play the queen check. Perhaps Fischer would have played the natural 5.Nf3, when the main move in ChessBase's 2023 Mega database, 5...Qh5, is disliked by Stockfish16 and Komodo14.1 on account of 6.Nc3, eg 6...Be6 7.Be2 Nf6 8.d4 with an unclear position.
6.Qe2 c6!?
This may be a tad slow. The engines reckon Black should develop a knight, eg 6...Nd7, and if 7.Nb5, perhaps the move Evans was worried about, then 7...0-0-0!?, when 8.Nxa7+ Kb8 9.Nb5 Ngf6 leaves Black powerfully ahead in development and equal on material.
7.Nf3 Qe7 8.d4 Bxc4 9.Qxc4 g5!?
The engines agree with 9...g5!?, which is about opening a diagonal for the black bishop as much as holding on to the f4 pawn
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
10.e5
Hoping to open lines to exploit White's lead in development and the awkward line-up of the black monarchs on the e file.
10...d5
Keeping lines closed, and doing it with tempo on the white queen.
11.Qd3
The engines prefer 11.Qb3!?
11...Na6 12.Ne2!? Nb4 13.Qd1 0-0-0 14.c3 Na6
How should White proceed?
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
15.h4!?
Playing on the side where your king has its address is usually frowned on, but Fischer, I presume, wanted to get at Black's awkward pawn-structure before Black could complete development and be better placed to defend it.
15...g4 16.Nh2 h5 17.Nxf4 Qxh4?
Temporarily winning a pawn, but the engines prefer 17...Qd7!?
18.Kg1
Freeing a square for the h2 knight, and protecting the king's rook.
18...Nh6 19.Nf1 Qe7 20.Nxh5
White has won his pawn back and threatens to go a pawn up.
20...Rg8 21.Nfg3 Rg6?!
The rook is a target here. The engines suggest 21...c5 or 21...Qe6.
22.Nf4 Rg5 23.Be3 Nc7?!
The engines suggest 23...f6.
24.Qd2 Rg8
Again the engines suggest ...f6, but it seems Black is losing material no matter what, eg 24...f6 25.exf6 Qxf6 26.Nfh5.
25.Nfe2
After a series of what seem sub-optimal moves, Black is losing  a piece.
25...f6 26.exf6 Qxf6 27.Bxh6 (1-0, 36 moves)

Monday, 2 October 2023

Refuting The King's Gambit III

FISCHER'S response to his defeat by Boris Spassky led to one of the most famous articles in chess history.
I have told something of the background to the article's publication, in the first issue of The American Chess Quarterly, in this post.
Fischer begins the article by complaining that modern annotators treat the opening with "kid gloves," analysing it "romantically - not scientifically."
He acknowledges the gambit is "making a comeback with the younger Soviet masters," but says Spassky admitted it gives White little, "but he plays it because neither does the Ruy Lopez nor the Giuoco Piano." 
Fischer dismisses lines in which Black declines the gambit, stating "the refutation of any gambit begins with accepting it."
His solution, after the moves 1.e4 e5 2.f4 exf4 3.Nf3, is to reject his choice against Spassky of  3...g5, which he condemns as "inexact because it gives White drawing chances in the ensuing ending ... where Black's extra pawn is neutralised by White's stranglehold on the dark squares, especially f4."*
[The phrase "ensuing ending" is a little odd, considering his encounter with Spassky never reached the endgame - Fischer resigned with each player still possessing a queen, a pair of rooks and a minor piece.]
Instead of 3...g5, Fischer recommends 3...d6, which he awards an exclamation mark, calling it "a high-class 'waiting move'."
Today 3...d6 is second in popularity to 3...g5, but before 1961, the date of the article's publication, 3...d6 also trailed 3...d5, 3...Be7 and 3...Nf6.
Fischer regarded 4.Bc4 as White's proper response, reckoning 4.d4 transposes.
However, this is far from obvious, and in Winning With The King's Gambit (Batsford 1992), Joe Gallagher cites the latter move as "clearly the most critical," while conceding "the plan of Bc4 followed by d3 is also interesting."
Fischer recommended meeting 4.Bc4 with 4...h6, which, like 3...d6, he awarded an exclamation mark, calling it the Berlin Defence Deferred, although today it is more-or-less universally known as the Fischer Defence.
He did not mention Gallagher's suggested 5.d3, instead continuing 5.d4 g5 6.0-0 Bg7 7.c3, claiming the last move is "necessary to protect the d pawn."
Quite a few alternatives have been missed along the way, and it is not even clear 7.c3 is "necessary," eg Stockfish16 for a long time prefers 7.Nc3 and 7.h4, although it does eventually list 7.c3 among its top two moves, at least for a while (Komodo14.1, however, agrees with Fischer's choice).
Position after 7.c3
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
Fischer then looks in some detail at 7...Nc6, citing authority for it being best, but adds in a note that he believes 7...Ne7 is best, annotating it with (!), adding "there is no reason why Black should not strive to castle kingside."
He continues with the sample line 8.g3 d5 (Fischer gives this an exclamation mark) 9.exd5 fxg3 10.hxg3 0-0 11.Qb3? Qd6 12.Kg2 Nf5 and "wins."
Unfortunately, as indicated, this analysis has a major flaw in it. The engines prefer, among other moves, 11.Nbd2, one point being 11...Qd6?! is now ineffective thanks to 12.Ne4.
Considering the article is so famous, it is short of detailed analysis. Rather, the sentiment behind it, and Fischer's eye for a catchy phrase, including the payoff: "Of course White can always play differently, in which case he merely loses differently," has helped keep it in the public eye.
*I have algebraicised the moves and quotes from the article.

Saturday, 30 September 2023

Refuting The King's Gambit

IN a recent post I pointed out Bobby Fischer took up the King's Gambit after he published his famous 'refutation' of the opening.
The story, briefly, is that Fischer lost to Boris Spassky on the black side of a King's Gambit at Argentina's 1960 Mar del Plata International.
Not only did he lose, but he lost relatively quickly - 29 moves - and apparently was reduced to tears (Fischer was 17 years old).
The following year, in the first issue of The American Chess Quarterly, he wrote A Bust To The King's Gambit.
The article was an instant success, not least thanks to Fischer's trenchant writing style, including: "In my opinion the King's Gambit is busted. It loses by force."
He concluded his analysis: "Of course White can always play differently, in which case he merely loses differently (Thank you, Weaver Adams!)."*
In 1963, at the US championship in New York, Fischer shocked the chess world by using the King's Gambit to beat Larry Evans.
But he did so by meeting 2...exf4 with 3.Bc4, which became his favourite weapon.
However Fischer twice tried 3.Nf3, with one of his opponents essaying Fischer's 'refutation'.
And what of Spassky? He apparently did not believe Fischer's Bust, as is evidenced by his continued success with the King's Gambit.

Here is probably a good point to interject a few words of caution.
When researching a subject such as this, it pays to double-check and, if possible, triple-check sources as myths are easily created and often repeated.
For example, a discussion at Chess.com of Romantic Openings includes the statement: "In 1960 (Mar del Plata) Spassky overwhelmed Fischer with a King's Gambit. Fischer wrote an article for American Chess Quarterly detailing his improved plan "refuting" the gambit, but Spassky used it again to beat Bronstein and Karpov. In fact, over his career Spassky won all 16 King's Gambits he played."
Whenever I see a statement as bold as this one, I instinctively think: "Can that really be true?" And if it is true, why on earth did Spassky not play the King's Gambit every chance he got?
A simple search of any decent database answers these questions.
ChessBase's 2023 Mega database has 31 games with Spassky on the white side of a King's Gambit. His score of +19=12-0 (81%), including wins against Furman and Najdorf as well as Bronstein and Karpov, is impressive, even though it does include games from simuls, but is not perfect.
Incidentally, the same database shows that all five times Spassky was on the black side of a King's Gambit, he won - perhaps that had something to do with his preference for 2.Nf3.
*Adams wrote a series of books and articles claiming White should win after 1.e4.
to be continued