I TRY to annotate games for Beau Chess as a neutral observer, seeking, with a big assist from engines, to get at the truth of what went on, not worrying about the number of question marks, etc, I award.
But looking afterwards at my round-seven game, in which I was White against Salvador Herrero Ferrando (1828), it is quite remarkable how many mistakes and blunders were committed in a short space of moves.
The mayhem began in the following position after Black's 12th move.
![]() |
| Black has just played the apparent-novelty 12...b6!? in what is clearly a sharp position with material and positional imbalances |
*****
*****
*****
*****
There followed 13.Be3? Bb7 14.Nxb6?? axb6? 15.Bxb6+ Ke7 16.a3 Bd6 17.c5?! Bb8 18.f3 Rc8 19.Nd4? d5? 20.cxd6+ Bxd6 21.Rc1? Nfd7??
In other words, I played three moves deserving a ?, one that received ??, and one that got away with ?!; my opponent played two moves that earned a ?, and one a ?? (a harsher annotator might have come close to wearing out the computer's question-mark key).
It all rather reminds me of the famous dictum - not, apparently, originally by Tartakower - that the winner of a game of chess is the player who makes the next-to-last mistake.
LESSON: if both players in a game fail to exercise basic tactical control, the outcome is almost reduced to random chance.







