Showing posts with label Botvinnik. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Botvinnik. Show all posts

Tuesday, 8 April 2025

Botvinnik Toppled

MIKHAIL Botvinnik, in his book One Hundred Selected Games, includes four games from his 1940 match against long-time training partner Viacheslav Ragozin.
The latter did not win a game in that match, but the following year, when they played five more games, Ragozin managed to win one, and I thought it would be interesting to look at how that happened.

Botvinnik - Ragozin
Queen's Gambit Declined
1.d4 d5 2.c4 e6 3.Nc3 Nf6 4.Bg5 Be7 5.Nf3 h6 6.Bxf6!?
More popular in ChessBase's 2025 Mega database is 6.Bh4, but Stockfish17 and Dragon1 marginally prefer the text at first, although they come to fluctuate between the two moves.
6...Bxf6 7.Qd3!?
This continuation has found few followers, although Jan Timman played it in a 1998 rapid game.
7...0-0 8.e4
White is not being subtle
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
8...dxe4
Ivan Ivanišević (2611) - Stelios Halkias (2588), Serbian Team Championship 2010, went 8...dxc4!? 9.Qxc4 c6 10.e5 Be7 11.Bd3 b6 12.Be4!? Bb7 13.Rd1!? Nd7 14.h4!? b5 15.Qb3 Qb6 16.0-0, with equal chances, according to the engines (½–½, 28 moves).
9.Qxe4!?
By transposition the game has reached a position occurring 28 times in Mega25.
9...c5 10.0-0-0!?
This is the move Botvinnik has apparently been leading up to. It is not liked by the engines.
10...cxd4 11.Nxd4 Qb6 12.Bd3 Rd8?!
Probably better is 12...g6, which was seen in two subsequent games.
13.Nb3!? Nd7?!
The engines prefer other moves, including, again, ...g6.
14.Qh7+ Kf8 15.Rhe1 Ne5 16.c5!? Qc7
There is no time to snap off the white bishop as 16...Nxd3+? 17.Rxd3 Qc7 can be met by 18.Rxd8+ Qxd8 19.Rd1, eg 19...Qc7 20.Rd6 Bxc3 21.bxc3 a5 22.Nd4!? with what seems a winning attack.
17.Bc2 Bd7?!
Even here the engines suggest 17...g6!?, or first exchanging a pair of rooks and then ...g6, even though White has Qxh6+.
How should White proceed?
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
18.Rd6?
The engines reckon both 18.Ne4 and 18.f4 win, whereas after the text they give Black the upper hand.
18...Be8?
This is much inferior to 18...Bc6, according to the engines.
19.Nd5!? exd5 20.Rxf6! gxf6 21.Qxh6+ Ke7 22.f4 d4 23.fxe5 fxe5
White is the exchange down, but has a winning move, according to the engines
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
24.Be4?
The engines reckon 24.Qh4+! wins, eg 24...f6 25.Rf1 Qc6 26.Na5 Qa6 27.Bd3! b5 28.a4!? Rac8 29.b4 Qe6 30.axb5 with a continuing attack. They also prefer other moves to the text, including 24.Rf1 and 24.Bd3.
24...a5!? 25.g4 Ra6 26.Qh4+ f6 27.g5 a4!? 28.Qh7+ Bf7 29.g6 Rf8
This difficult game has reached a completely equal position, according to the engines, but it is White to play and lose
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
30.gxf7?
Now the black king is safe (better was 30,Nxd4! Qxc5+ 31.Nc2), but after ...
30...axb3
... the white king is open to attack.
Botvinnik resigned as there is nothing better than 31.a3, when 31...Qxc5+ is good enough, but even better is first 31...Rxf7 as ...Qxc5+ cannot be stopped.

Sunday, 16 February 2025

Opening Knowledge

A FRIEND complained this week I had not written much recently about openings.
Well here is a game that features instructive notes by a future world champion in action against a future world correspondence champion.
Notes in italics are algebraicised from Mikhail Botvinnik's 100 Selected Games.
Opening theory has moved on since the book was first published in the Soviet Union in 1949, but Botvinnik's general observations are still pertinent.

Mikhail Botvinnik -Viacheslav Ragozin
Match (Leningrad) 1940
Slav Defence
1.d4 d5 2.c4 c6 3.Nc3!? Nf6
Since the eighth game of the Keres-Euwe match (1940), 3...dxc4 is rarely played - the variation 4.e4 e5 5.Nf3 exd4 6.Qxd4 is obviously in White's favour.
Today 3...dxc4!? is more respectable, the idea usually being to meet 4.e4 with 4...b5!?, eg 5.a4 b4 6.Na2 Nf6 7.e5 Nd5 8.Bxc4 e6, with equality, according to Stockfish17 and Dragon1.
4.e3!?
The main move is 4.Nf3, while also popular is 4.cxd5. Garry Kasparov has tried all three.
4...g6
With the order of moves White has chosen (3.Nc3, and not 3.Nf3), 4...Bf5 is bad because of 5.cxd5 cxd5 6.Qb3. But if Black does not wish to play 4...e6 either - it may lead to the Meran Variation - he cannot do better than play the Schlechter Variation (4...g6).
Stockfish17 disagrees, reckoning 4...Bf5 5.cxd5 cxd5 6.Qb3 can be met by 6...Nc6!?, a move that first appears in ChessBase's 2025 Mega database in 1998. After 7.Qxb7 Bd7 8.Qb3 Rb8 9.Qd1!? e5 the engines judge Black's compensation for a pawn to be just about sufficient.
5.Nf3 Bg7
This position occurs 12,343 times in Mega25, going back to at least Pillsbury - Gunsberg, Hastings 1895 (1-0, 40 moves)
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
6.Bd3 0-0 7.0-0 Bg4!?
A dubious system of development in use 25 years ago [ie the mid-1920s]. True, Black has solved the problem of development of the QB, but he leaves White the advantage of the pair of bishops.
The text is the engines' top choice.
8.h3 Bxf3 9.Qxf3 dxc4?!
A positional error. White's two bishops may be powerful if the game is opened, so Black should not have exchanged in the centre. 9...e6 is more logical.
Ragozin apparently agreed as in later games he played 9...e6 and, once, 9...e5?
10.Bxc4 Nbd7 11.Rd1 e5
Bogoljubow, against Marshall (Baden-Baden 1925), played 11...Ne8, but did not equalise the game. The text move also is no novelty; it occurred in a Bogoljubow-Rabinovich game, played in the USSR Fourth Championship (Leningrad 1925).
Now, of course, it is not in White's interest to play 12.dxe5 Nxe5, but he can operate on the d file with d5. This has the advantage that Black's bishop remains blocked.
12.d5 c5?
Rabinovich played 12...Qc7 and was left with an inferior game.
The text seems even worse. The correct treatment of the position was introduced by Lidia Semenova (2225) in her 1983 women candidates' quarter-final match, ie 12...e4! 13.Nxe4 Nxe4 14.Qxe4 Nb6, eg 15.Bb3 cxd5 16.Bxd5 Re8!? 17.Qf3 Nxd5 18.Rxd5, when 18...Qc7 leaves Black with good compensation for a pawn (Stcokfish17) or at most slightly worse (Dragon1).
13.d6!
This move should be made before e4 as White, in attacking the b7 pawn with his queen, gains a tempo.
13...Rb8 14.e4 Ne8
Black makes an attempt to capture the d pawn, but nothing comes of it. Moreover, even if he were to succeed, White would still have the better position as he would control files for his pieces. White's sole danger would arise if Black could transfer a knight to d4, but he cannot.
15.Be3 a6 16.a4 Rc8
Of course, neither now nor earlier could Black play ...Qb6, because of Nd5, and if ...Qxb2 then Bg5, leading to capture of the queen.
The point is that after 16...Qb6?! 17.Nd5 Qxb2? the move 18.Bg5!? (there are also other strong continuations) more-or-less obliges Black to play 18...Nxd6, when 19.Ra2 wins (18.Ra2 is even more straightforward).
17.Rd2 h6
The attempt to win the pawn could still be refuted by various means. The simplest would be 17...Rc6 18.Rad1 Nb6 19.Bd5 Nxd5 20.Rxd5, and White breaks through Black's front. Nor is the manoeuvre ...Nb8-c6-d4 possible.
Black is preparing 18...Nef6, which if played at once would be dubious because of 18.Bg5. In addition his aim is to transfer his e8 knight through f6/h7/g5/e6 to d4.
18.Rad1 Nef6 19.Nd5
White prevents the above-mentioned knight manoeuvre, and every exchange increases the strength of the d pawn.
19...Nxd5
19...Nh7?? 20.Ne7+ etc.
20.Bxd5 Rb8 21.Qe2 Kh7 22.Rc2 Qf6?!
This is a serious error. The c pawn needs protection, so Black should have played 22...Qa5, and although after 23.b3 all Back's pieces occupy passive positions, there is no obvious immediate threat to them. Even so, because of the pawn on d6, White's win is only a matter of time.
23.Ba2 Rbc8
Otherwise 24.Bxc5.
The engines suggest 23...b5!?, albeit agreeing White is winning.
24.b4
Black has no way of defending the c pawn, so he is forced to let the white rook penetrate to the seventh rank.
24...cxb4 25.Rc7 Rxc7
This of course speeds the denouement, but it is obvious that against White's two powerful bishops, the pawn on d6, a rook on the seventh rank, and equality in material, the 'struggle' would not be very interesting.
26.dxc7 Nb6
26...Qc6 could be met by 27.Qc4.
27.Bxb6 Qxb6 28.Qc4 Rc8 29.Rd7 Qc6 30.Qxc6 bxc6 31.Rxf7 c5 32.Be6 1-0

Thursday, 19 December 2024

Fiery Dragon

HERE is an exciting and instructive game from Mikhail Botvinnik's One Hundred Selected Games.
Notes in italics are from the book.

Ilya Kan - Mikhail Botvinnik
Moscow 1936
Sicilian Dragon
1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 d6 3.d4 cxd4 4.Nxd4 Nf6 5.Nc3 g6 6.Be2 Bg7 7.Be3 Nc6 8.Nb3!?
Am idea deserving serious attention. White has in mind an immediate pawn-attack on the kingside, while Black has no better continuation than 8...Be6 and 9...0-0, as otherwise White will castle short, and then a well-known variation unfavourable to Black will result.
More popular than the text were, and still are, 8.Qd2 and especially 8.0-0. For what it is worth, Stockfish17 very marginally prefers the former, while Dragon1 favours the text.
8...Be6
It is hard to know what Botvinnik's "well-known variation unfavourable to Black" may be. Certainly nothing obvious jumps out from ChessBase's 2024 Mega database.
9.f4 0-0 10.g4!?
How should Black meet White's pawn-storm?
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
10...Na5?!
In reply to White's flank attack, Black should have undertaken an active counterattack in the centre by 10...d5! Now White's attack grows dangerous.
The text is by far the commonest continuation in Mega24, but is strongly disliked by Stockfish17 and Dragon1. They suggest 10...Rc8 or 10...a5, but reckon Botvinnik's recommendation is a mistake thanks to the reply 11.f5. This was played later the same year at Nottingham in the game Alexander Alekhine - Botvinnik, which continued 11...Bc8!? 12.exd5 Nb4, after which the engines reckon 13.Bf3 gives White the upper hand, as subsequent games seemed to show.
11.g5 Ne8
This is unquestionably better than 11...Nd7 as afterwards the knight can occupy g7, where it is useful for defence.
The latter move is almost five times more popular in Mega24, and is the top choice of Stockfish17, whereas Dragon1 agrees with Botvinnik's assessment.
12.Qd2
White determines the queen's position prematurely. The correct move is 12.Bd4 at once, as [Jan] Foltys played against [Erich] Eliskases (Poděbrady, Czechoslovakia, 1936).
The engines marginally prefer Kan's move.
12...Rc8!?
Sacrificing the a7 pawn. White refuses the sacrifice, for after 13...Bc4 it would lose several important tempi and relinquish the initiative to Black.
The engines agree 13.Bxa7? is a mistake, but reckon the correct reply is 13...Bxc3!? 14.bxc3 Nc4 or the immediate 13..Nc4. The problem with 13...Bc4, according to them, is the simple 14.Bd4, when they reckon White is at least equal.
13.Bd4 Nc4
Stronger is 13...Bc4, eg 14.0-0-0 is followed by 14...Bxe2 15.Nxe2 (or 15.Qxe2) Nc4, and the knight's strong position gives Black opportunities of counterattack.
The engines prefer the text, but agree with Botvinnik's analysis of his main variation, with the major exception that they reckon meeting 15.Qxe2 with ...Nc4 gives White a winning attack starting with 16.h4. Instead they recommend 15...e5!?, claiming complete equality.
14.Bxc4 Rxc4 15.0-0-0 Qd7 16.Qd3 Rc8!?
After this passive move the initiative passes to White. Black should have continued 16...b5 with an approximately equal game.
The engines agree 16...b5 is a little better, but reckon White anyway has an edge.
17.h4 Bg4
Black must prevent the opening of the h file.
18.Rd2
Retreat to e1 would be more exact. The rook's position on the same diagonal as the king provides Black with combinative possibilities.
18...b6?!
Botvinnik does not comment on this defensive move, but it seems a serious mistake. The engines give 18...f5, albeit awarding White a slight edge.
19.Nd5
If 19.Bxg7 then 19...Nxg7 20.Nd5 Be6 21.Nd4 Rc5, and Black has fully equal play.
The engines prefer 19.Bxg7, their point being to meet 19...Nxg7 with 20.Rg1!?, eg 20...f5 21.e5 Rfd8 22.Qd5+ Qe6 23.Nd4!? Qxd5 24.Nxd5, claiming White has the upper hand.
19...e5
With passive play Black would be slowly asphyxiated after f5.
20.Bc3
Apparently 20.f5 is also without danger to Black, because of 20...exd4 21.f6 Nxf6 22.gxf6 Bh6 23.Ne7+ Kh8 24.Nxc8 Rxc8.
The engines agree with the assessment of the result of that line, but reckon sacrificing the exchange with 23.Kb1!? Bxd2 24.Qxd2 gives White a slight edge.
20...f5?!
The engines reckon Black needed to play 20...Nc7 or possibly 20...f6.
Position after 20...f5?!
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
An extremely sharp and complex position has arisen. To 21.fxe5 Black can simply reply 21...dxe5.
The engines continue 22.Qa6! with what seems a winning advantage as Black has apparently unsolvable problems saving his queen without losing material, eg 22...Nd6 23.Bb4 Rcd8 24.Qa3! Nc4 25.Ne7+ Qxe7 (or 25...Kf7 26.Rxd7 Nxa3 27.Rb7! etc) 26.Bxe7 Nxa3 27.Rxd8, winning the exchange.
Possibly strongest of all now for White is 21.exf5 Bxf5 22.Qe2, and White preserves his knight at d5. The continuation White chooses gives the advantage to Black.
21.gxf6?! Nxf6 22.Nxf6+ Rxf6 23.Qd5+?
Nothing in 23.fxe5 Rf3 24.Qd5+ Be6 25.Qxd6 Bh6 26.Nd4 Rh3!, and White does not get adequate compensation for the exchange.
The engines reckon this line gives White full compensation.
23...Rf7!
The move that decides the game! If now 24.Qxd6 then 24...Qxd6 25.Rxd6 exf4, or 24.fxe5 Be6 25.Qxd6 Bh6, and White is in a bad way.
Now White makes a pawn sacrifice, which gives him nothing and only speeds up his loss.
24.h5 gxh5 25.Rg1
In sacrificing the pawn White evidently overlooked that after 25.fxe5 dxe5 26.Qxd7 Bxd7 27.Rxh5 Rf1+ 28.Rd1 Rxd1 29.Kxd1 Bg4+ he is a rook down.
25...Qc6 26.fxe5 dxe5!?
The strong passed h pawn secures Black the win. So there is no sense in complicating the game by winning the exchange at the price of laying bare his king's position.
In other words, Botvinnik is saying that 26...Bh6, while it may be objectively stronger, as the engines agree, increases the chances of Black going wrong.
27.Qxc6 Rxc6 28.Rd5 Rcf6 29.Nd2
The continuation 29.Bxe5 leads to loss of material because of 29...Rf1+ 30.Rxf1 Rxf1+ 31.Kd2 Rd1+.
29...Bh6 30.b3 Rf2 31.Kb2
31.Rxe5 does not save the game because of 31...Rh2 ( to defend the h5 pawn), followed by 32...Rff2.
31...Re2?
Botvinnik does not comment on this. It seems both players missed that this throws away Black's advantage, which would remain more-or-less decisive, according to the engines, after 31...Bg5 or 31...b5.
32.Nc4 Rff2 33.Rd8+ Bf8
The engines slightly prefer moving the king, or 33...Rf8.
How should White continue?
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
34.b4?
White's game is lost, but even so he should have chosen 34.Rc8, although here also the advance of the h pawn is decisive.
The engines reckon 34.Rc8?? is even worse than the text, but that 34.Kb1 gives complete equality, and 34.Be1! may even lead a to a tiny edge, eg 34...Rxc2+ 35.Kb1 Rxc4! (moving the f2 rook along White's second rank allows 36.Rf1) 36.bxc4.
34...Rxc2+ 35.Kb3 Rg2 36.Rf1?
Better are 36.Rxg2 and 36.Bxe5!
36...Rcf2 37.Rxf2 Rxf2 38.Nxe5 Be6+ 39.Ka4 Rxa2+ 40.Kb5 Rc2 41.Rd3 h4 42.Bd4 Bg7 43.Ra3 h3 44.Rxa7 h2 45.Ra8+ Bc8 46.Ra1 Bh3 47.Nf3 Bxd4 48.Nxd4 Rf2 0-1

Sunday, 29 September 2024

What Would You Play?

THE following very interesting position arose in the game Mikhail Botvinnk - Nikolay Sorokin, USSR Championship (Moscow) 1931.
Black has just played 19...e6-e5!?
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
Botvinnik replied 20.Qe3!?
He wrote in One Hundred Selected Games: "This far-from-obvious move is the strongest in the given position. With the exchange of queens, which he cannot avoid, the defects of Black's position grow more perceptible. In view of the backwardness of his development Black now certainly cannot oppose anything to the pressure along the d file. His e pawn becomes very weak. To defend it Black finds himself forced to exchange a bishop for a knight at f3, after which not only his queenside but the square f7 is weakened. The doubling of the white pawns on the e file is of no essential importance."
Botvinnik awarded his move an exclamation mark, something he was rather sparing with.
Valery Chekov, annotating the game for ChessBase, also gives the move an exclamation mark, but without comment.
So far, so interesting, and arguably rather instructional, but what makes the position even more interesting is that modern engines strongly disagree with the grandmasters' verdict. 
Stockfish17 and Dragon1 fluctuate between calling the move dubious (flashing yellow) and calling it a mistake (flashing red).
The former reckons both 20.Rc2 and 20.Rd6 give a winning position, while Dragon1 agrees on 20.Rd6 but assesses 20.Qe3!? as second-best, albeit 'only' good enough for the upper hand.
Who to believe?
If the situation were tactical, there is usually - I stress 'usually', rather than invariably - little doubt engines' verdicts are the more reliable.
But the situation is positional, and, to a certain extent, Dragon1, at least, is unsure as to the best continuation (20.h3 and 20.Rc2 get a look-in as being second-best, with the later sometimes overtaking 20.Rd6 as Dragon1's preferred option).
All-in-all, perhaps it is best to sum up the verdict as unclear.

Saturday, 28 September 2024

Select

WHILE I was in America the only chess book I took with me was Mikhail Botvinnik's One Hundred Selected Games.
The following is an exciting encounter from the 1931 Leningrad Championship, with notes in italics by the author.

Mikhail Botvinnik - Grigoriy Myasoyedov
Nimzo-Indian
1.d4 Nf6 2.C4 e6 3.Nc3 Bb4 4.Qb3!?
This move is out of favour today, but was played as early 1882 - four years before Aron Nimzowitsch was born - by Wilhelm Steinitz.
4...c5 5.dxc5!?
This is easily the most popular continuation in ChessBase's 2024 Mega database.
5...Nc6!? 6.Nf3 Ne4!? 7.Bd2 Nxc5!?
Much more common is 7...Nxd2, but Nimzowitsch preferred the text in a 1930 win over Efim Bogoljubow.
8.Qc2 f5 9.a3 Bxc3 10.Bxc3 0-0 11.b4 Ne4
Position after 11...Ne4
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
So far as in the Stahlberg-Alekhine game (Hamburg 1930*), which ended in White's defeat. In commenting on that game Kmoch pointed out that instead of the 12.e3 which was played the best continuation was 12.Bb2 b6, though this also was in Black's favour. The present game seems to show that even in that case Black's game is no better.
12.Bb2 b6
Simpler would have been 12...d6, as in the game Winter-Sultan Khan (Hastings Christmas 1930). But now a little surprise awaits Black.
13.g4!?
This interesting move had been previously studied in home analysis and, now at last, applied in practice. If I had foreseen what complications this novelty would lead to I would in all probability have given preference to the calm continuation 13.g3.
How should Black respond?
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
13...Nxf2!
All other continuations led to opening up the g file, after which White's position, with the bishop at b2 and the rook at g1 would look threatening. For that matter, White had taken this knight sacrifice also into account. I foresaw that Black would not be able to recapture, and ended my analysis at that. But, as often happens, mistakes occur in home analysis too, to be refuted by actual play. White does in fact retain his piece, but he comes under strong attack.
14.Kxf2 fxg4 15.Rg1 Qh4+ 16.Ke3
It is easy to see that this is now the only move. If 16.Rg3 [then] 16...gxf3 17.Kg1 Nd4!, or 16.Kg2 gxf3+ 17.Kh1 Nd4! to Black's advantage.
16...Qh6+ 17.Kf2 Qh4+
Black is compelled  to resort to perpetual check. A false scent would be 17...Qxh2+ 18.Rg2! Or 17...gxf3 18.Rxg7+ Qxg7 19.Bxg7, and White alone would gain.
18.Ke3 Qh6+ 19.Kd3
This is the very position White has studied, regarding it as favourable to himself. However, at the board, only after great hesitation did he decide on taking the king for such a daring walk.
19...d5
The strongest move! There was nothing good to be obtained from 19...Qg6+ 20.Kd2, or 19...e5 20.Qd2! Qd6+ 21.Kc2.
20.Qc1?!
The only reply, securing the king's retreat. Not 20.Qd2 Qg6+ 21.Kc3 Qe4! 22.Qg5 e5!, and White's position is critical.
Stockfish17 and Dragon1 much prefer 20.Qd2, improving on Botvinnik's line with 22.cxd5, claiming complete equality.
Now it may appear that White is getting out of the wood, but Black, consistently developing his attack on the White king, in the final resort achieves perpetual check.
20...dxc4+
ChessBase gives the last two moves exclamation marks, as indeed did Botvinnik. In fact ChessBase appears to have lifted Botvinnik's annotations wholesale without attribution. The engines show 20...Rf4!? would have caused White serious problems as both 21...e5 and 21...dxc4+ are major threats, eg 21.Ne5 Bb7 22.h3 Nxe5+ 23.Bxe5 Qg6+ 24.Kd2 Re4 25.Bb2 h5!? with a complicated position that the engines reckon is winning for Black
21.Qxc4
21.Kxc4 is bad: 21...Rf4+ 22.Kb3 e5! But it was worth considering 21.Kc2 (leaving the c file [half-]closed) though Black's three pawns for the piece made this continuation unconvincing.
21...Rd8+ 22.Kc2 Bb7 23.Qxg4
Now the threat Qxg7+ drives Black into the following continuation, forcing a draw.
23...Nxb4+! 24.axb4
Agreeing to a draw.
24...Rac8+ 25.Bc3 Rxc3+! 26.Kxc3 Qe3+ 27.Kb2 Rd2+! 28.Nxd2 Qxd2+ 29.Kb1 Qd1+ 30.Kb2 Qd2+ ½–½
*At the third Olympiad.

Monday, 16 September 2024

Take A Break

I AM taking a short break from chess to go on holiday, and accordingly flew to San Francisco yesterday.
The idea is to walk in five iconic national parks in the American Southwest, starting with Yosemite.
Because I am on holiday, I have only taken along one chess book, Mikhail Botvinnik's One Hundred Selected Games, for some light reading.
Coincidentally, in the foreword, Botvinnik touches on a subject I covered in my last Torquay post, namely whether to go for a deep but narrow repertoire or one that is wide but shallow.
Botvinnik writes: "A player should not, and indeed cannot attempt to play all the openings known to theory.
"For one competition three or four opening systems for White and the same for Black are quite sufficient. But these systems must be prepared thoroughly.
"If you do not have such systems at your command you can hardly count on finishing very high in the table."
He adds: "But it is also very unsatisfactory for a master to play only one opening; his opponents will be well prepared for play against him, and above all his chess horizon will be too narrow, [and] in many positions he will simply play by rote."
Whether Botvinnik's words support a deep but narrow repertoire, or tend to favour a wide but shallow one, may be a matter of opinion, but it is worth bearing in mind he was writing in the late 1940s, long before the age of databases.
View from my hotel window of a cable car going by on one of San Francisco's three remaining cable-car lines

Thursday, 2 May 2024

Rare Treat

THE following gem of a game has several unusual features.
For starters, it shows Mikhail Botvinnik on the losing side.
Not only that, but he loses in 26 moves after going pawn-grabbing ... twice.
Notes in italics are by Savielly Tartakower and Julius du Mont, algebraicised from 500 Master Games Of Chess.

Ilya Kan - Mikhail Botvinnik
Moscow 1935
Vienna Gambit
1.e4 e5
The future world champion would become famous for his love of the French Defence, but in this tournament, in which he shared first place with Salo Flohr, he only met 1.e4 with 1...e5, although Botvinnik did get a French after replying to 1.d4 with 1...e6.
2.Nc3 Nf6 3.f4 d5 4.fxe5 Nxe4 5.Nf3 Nc6 6.Qe2
A grave disappointment would result from a quiet developing continuation by 6.Be2, eg 6...Bc5 (threat: 7...Nf2, "mating" the queen) 7.d4 Nxd4 (a cruel surprise) 8.Nxd4 Qh4+ 9.g3 Nxg3 10.Nf3 Bf2+ (more trouble) 11.Kxf2 Ne4+ 12.Ke3 Qh6+ (more convincing even than 12...Qf7+) 13.Kd4 c5+ 14.Kxd5 Qc6+ 15.Kc4 Be6+ and wins.
Position after 15...Be6+
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
This is a fascinating line, but it is far from clear White is lost at the end of it.
After 16.Kd3 Nf2+ (stronger than 16...0-0-0+, according to Stockfish16 and Komodo14.1) 17.Ke3 Nxd1+ 18.Rxd1 White has three minor pieces, including the bishop-pair, for queen and pawn. Komodo14.1 believes Black is winning, but Stockfish16 gives Black only a slight edge.
The engines reckon Black has a significant improvement with 13...Qb6+!? 14.Kd3 Nf2+ 15.Kd2 Nxd1. After 16.Kxd1 (or 16.Rxd1) Black has a pawn more than in the authors' line, and the black queen is more active.
Everything up to 12...Qh6+ was seen in Torsten Lang (2374) - Tobias Bärwinkel (2319), German League 2007. That game continued 13.Ng5?! Qxg5+ 14.Kd4 Qh4? (14...c5+) 15.Nxe4 Qxe4+ 16.Kc3 d4+ 17.Kb3 0-0 with an unclear position (1-0, 48 moves).
6...Bf5 7.Qb5?!
An optimistic sally, which - succeeds! Caution dictates 7.d3.
The engines strongly agree with this, although in ChessBase's 2024 Mega database the text scores 33%, two percentage points higher than 7.d3.
7...Nc5
Instinctively, Black wants to protect his two pawns (d5 and b7). A reply which meets the case is at once 7...a6, and then if 8.Qxb7 or 8.Qxd5 [then] 8...Nb4, which shows that the white queen has entered the fray without due preparation.
8.d4 a6 9.Qe2 Ne4?!
The engines reckon Black is better after 9...Ne6, as played by Joseph Blackburne in a win over George Gossip at the 1889 USA Congress in New York.
10.Qe3!?
White has restored the balance, and now maintains the superior grouping of his forces (a good centre, open f file, etc). The 'pawn sacrifice' is basically sound.
10...Nxc3 11.bxc3 Bxc2
Accepting the Greek gift.
12.Qf2 Bf5 13.Ne4 Be6
The engines prefer the more-active 13...Be4.
14.Bd3
Well developed at the price of a pawn, this bishop is becoming very active.
14...Qd7 15.0-0 Na5 16.Nf5 0-0-0
Or 16...g6 17.Nh4 with fresh targets.
Now both sides have castled, how would you assess the position?
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
As usual, positions with opposite-side castling are hard to evaluate. Komodo14.1 claims complete equality, but Stockfish16 gives Black a slight edge.
17.Qe2 Qc6 18.Rb1!? h6
Not 18...Qxc3? 19.Bd2 Qa3 20.Bxa6! etc.
19.Bd2 Nc4 20.Ne3 Nxe3!? 21.Bxe3 Qxc3?
Having had, at all times, a difficult game, Black has at least secured an advantage in material. As against this, the new [half-]open file will soon make itself felt.
Botvinnik's decision to grab a second pawn is extraordinary. Most club players, I believe, would avoid this error even if they could not see how it would be refuted.
22.Rfc1 Qa5 23.Qc2
The final assault.
23...c6 24.Bd2 Qc7 25.Qa4
All White's forces are cooperating. The two-fold threat now is 26.Bxa6 and 26.Ba5.
25...Rd7
There is no saving clause.
26.Bxa6! 1-0

Thursday, 15 October 2020

Chess Evolution: QGD Exchange (part four)

TWO of White's earliest plans in the Exchange Variation of the Queen's Gambit Declined were the Minority Attack (pawn-thrusts on the queenside) and opposite-side castling (aiming for a kingside piece-and-pawn attack).
As Black adjusted to these, a third plan became popular: a central pawn-advance.
Mikhail Botvinnik - Bent Larsen
Noordwijk (Netherlands) 1965
1.c4 e6 2.Nc3 d5
Playing 1...e6 and 2...d5 can be used as a universal system against just about everything, including 1.d4, 1.c4, 1.Nf3 and 1.e4.
3.d4 Nf6 4.cxd5 exd5 5.Bg5 c6
This move is second in popularity to 5...Be7. Black nearly always plays ...c6 at some point in the QGD Exchange, but some people believe playing ...c6 early is rather committal in that Black might want to play ...c5 in one move, for example if White castles long. On the other hand, 5...c6 can be the prelude to a radical plan, popularised by Nigel Short, involving an early ...Bf5. I will cover this later in the series.
6.e3 Be7
Larsen is happy to transpose to the main line.
7.Qc2 0-0 8.Bd3 Nbd7 9.Nge2
This development of the king's knight has overtaken 9.Nf3 in popularity in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database.
9...h6!? 10.Bh4 Re8 11.f3!?
White starts to advance in the centre, while holding back on committing his king to either flank.
11...c5!?
If Black dithers, he can easily get overrun in the centre. The text, first played in this game, is today the most-popular response to 11.f3!?
12.0-0
Botvinnik goes short. The move Nge2 has been played with a view to castling long, especially when Black has created a kingside target by playing ...h6. Here Botvinnik may have felt 12.0-0-0!? was rather unclear.
12...a6 13.Rad1 b5 14.Bf2?!
Black is ready to expand into White's side of the board on the queenside, and it seems this pawn-storm should be broken up with 14.dxc5 Bxc5 15.Nd4, with a roughly equal game, according to my main analysis engines Stockfish12 and Komodo11.01.
14...c4 15.Bf5 Nb6
Forcing light-square bishops off can be regarded as a major success for Black, although the engines prefer 15...b4!?, continuing 16.Na4 Nb6 with advantage to Black (winning, according to Stockfish12, but just a slight edge, according to Komodo11.01).
16.Ng3 Bf8 17.a3 Bb7?!
A strange decision. It is not as if ...Bb7 prevents White playing e4. Perhaps Larsen thought his light-square bishop would become powerful after exchanges on e4, but that does not happen.
18.e4 g6 19.Bh3 a5
The problem with 19...dxe4?! is that, after 20.fxe4, White's hanging pawns are not weak, but instead threaten to drive back the black pieces.
20.e5 b4 21.Nce2
Not 21.exf6? bxc3 22.bxc3 Qxf6 - the e pawn is too powerful to be swopped in this way.
21...Nh7
It seems Black did not have to be so quick about withdrawing the knight. One line given by the engines runs 21...Bc6!? 22.Rde1 Ba4 23.Qb1, with a possible continuation being 23...Bd7 24.Bxd7 Nfxd7, although after 25.f4 White's kingside plays looks much more effective than Black's queenside counterplay.
22.f4 Bc6 23.Rda1 Ba4 24.Qb1 f5?!
The engines give 24...c3 25.b3 Bb5, albeit with advantage to White.
25.axb4 axb4
How should White proceed?
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
26.Nxf5! gxf5 27.Bxf5 Qe7
The engines prefer 27...Qc7!?, their main line running 28.Bg6 Rec8 29.Re1 Kh8 30.f5 with advantage to White.
28.Ng3?!
This largely lets Black off the hook. Much stronger seems to be 28.Bg6, when the engines reckon Black has to give up the exchange as, after the king's rook moves, say to c8, 29.f5 is very powerful.
28...Bd7?!
The engines reckon Black gets good counterplay with 28...Bb5, for example 29.Re1 Rxa1 30.Qxa1 Ra8.
29.Bxd7 Nxd7 30.Qg6+ Qg7 31.Qc6 Rxa1 32.Rxa1
White is still material down - a knight for two pawns - but his pieces are better coordinated and the white f and g pawns are more of a threat than the black b and c pawns.
32...Qf7 33.Ra7 Nxe5??
Larsen cracks under the pressure. The engines reckon 33...Nb8 keeps Black in the game, although they prefer White after 34.Qa4.
34.dxe5 Qe6 35.Qxe6+ Rxe6 36.Nf5
Black is only a pawn down materially, but in reality he is the equivalent of at least a piece down, according to the engines.
36...Rc6 37.Kf1 c3 38.bxc3 bxc3 39.Be3 Bc5
This loses the h6 pawn, but Black has virtually run out of moves, eg 39...c2 40.Bc1 Rc4 runs into 41.e6.
40.Bxc5 Rxc5 41.Ra1
Arguably simpler is 41.Nxh6+ followed by 42.Ra1, but Botvinnik decides Black has so many weaknesses he does not need to pick up the h6 pawn.
41...Nf8 42.Ke2 Ne6 43.g3 h5
At last Larsen feels compelled to move his h pawn off-prise, as Nigel Davies would put it, as otherwise he is in danger of going two pawns down.
44.Kd3 d4 45.Nd6
Not 45.Nxd4? Rd5 46.Ra4 Nxd4! 47.Rxd4?? Rxd4 48.Kxd4 c2 etc.
45...Rc7 46.Ne4 Kh7 47.f5 Nd8 48.Nf6+ Kh6 49.Nd5 Rb7 50.e6 Nc6 51.Ra6 Ne5+
Or 51...Ne7 52.Nxe7 Rxe7 53.f6 etc.
52.Kxd4 1-0

Sunday, 27 September 2020

Chess Evolution: The French Defence (part 11)

AS international chess returned to normal, and indeed increased, after World War One, there was a big question mark over the Winawer: 1.e4 e6 2.d4 d5 3.Nc3 Bb4.
The statistics bear this out. Of the games with 1.e4 e6 2.d4 d5 3.Nc3 from 1919-27 in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database, 358 continued with the Classical: 3...Nf6 compared with just 105 for 3...Bb4.
The main reason for the relative unpopularity of 3...Bb4 was 4.exd5, which was played in 67 of the 105 games.
It was thought that switching into a line of the Exchange Variation: 1.e4 e6 2.d4 d5 3.exd5 was detrimental to Black because in that variation the black dark-square bishop was believed to be best-placed on d6.
Then came game one of the Capablanca - Alekhine world championship, in which Capablanca played 4.exd5 against Alekhine's Winawer and lost.
From 1928-39, when World War Two brought another cessation to most international chess, 3...Nf6 featured in 631 Mega20 games compared with 262 for 3...Bb4.
In other words the percentage of Winawer games, compared with Classical, rose from 22.7% to 29.3%.
That was significant, but even more dramatic was the eclipse of 4.exd5 as the preferred answer to the Winawer.
It was played 63.8% of the time from 1919-27 but just 16.8% from 1928-39.
The new kid on the block - actually, not so new but suddenly much more popular - was 4.e5, which accounted for 55% of the games from 1928-39.
The main champion of the Winawer became Mikhail Botvinnik. He played it throughout the 1930s, continued (when he could) during World War Two and kept faith with it in the 1948 tournament to decide who should replace the deceased Alekhine as world champion.
Samuel Reshevsky - Mikhail Botvinnik
1948 World Championship Round 19
French Winawer
1.d4 e6 2.e4 d5 3.Nc3 Bb4 4.e5 c5 5.a3
This is now firmly established as the main move but for a long time it played second fiddle to 5.Bd2.
5...Bxc3+!?
Botvinnik won with 5...Ba5 against the same opponent two years earlier at Moscow in a match between the Soviet Union and the US.
6.bxc3 Qc7 7.Qg4!?
Reshevsky was noted for his positional play, while also excelling at tactics. At the time this game was played, the main move was the non-forcing 7.Nf3, but here Reshevsky aims to take advantage of Black's vulnerability on the kingside dark squares.
7...f5!?
A major alternative is 7...Ne7, transposing to a position normally reached via the move-order 6...Ne7 7.Qg4 Qc7.
8.Qg3!?
The first game in Mega20 to feature this move, which is now standard.
8...cxd4 9.cxd4 Ne7 10.Bd2
Not 10.Qxg7?? Rg8 and 11...Qc3+ etc.
10...0-0 11.Bd3
Defending c2 and hoping to later lever open the b1-h7 diagonal.
In many lines of the Winawer with Qg4, Black sacrifices one or two kingside pawns in return for dynamic piece-play on the queenside and in the centre. Here material is level but positionally unbalanced - White has more space and kingside attacking chances, while Black has pressure down the half-open c file and generally the better of it on the queenside.
White also has the bishop-pair, although the blocked centre means that is not an advantage at present. Nevertheless Black has a bad bishop, so Botvinnik sets about exchanging it.
11...b6 12.Ne2 Ba6 13.Nf4 Qd7 14.Bxa6!?
The point of voluntarily exchanging is that the black queen's knight has few immediate prospects on a6.
14...Nxa6 15.Qd3 Nb8 16.h4 Nbc6 17.Rh3 Rac8 18.Rg3 Kh8
Kasparov (2795) - Short (2690), Novgorod (USSR) 1997, saw 18...Rf7 19.h5 Nd8 20.c3* with an edge for White, according to the analysis engines Stockfish11 and Komodo11.01 (1-0, 31 moves).
19.h5 Rf7 20.h6 g6 21.Rc1!?
A rule-of-thumb from Cecil Purdy, the first world correspondence champion, was to never put a rook behind an unmoved pawn, even if you intend to move the pawn fairly quickly. Such rules are often broken, correctly, but here the engines much prefer 21.a4 or 21.Kf1!?
21...Rff8!? 22.Nd2
White's kingside pressure has not resulted in a breakthrough, but he still has an edge, according to the engines. However, Black now has time to try to work up an initiative on the queenside.
22...Nb8!?
Opening a line for the queen's rook, but the engines are unimpressed, preferring 22...Nd8 with the idea of proceeding with ...Nf7!?
23.Kf1 Rc4
A rook in the middle of the board in a crowded middlegame can easily get into trouble, but it will be hard for the white knight to harass it.
24.Kg1 Nbc6!? 25.Bg5 Ng8 26.Re1 Qf7 27.c3 Na5
Botvinnik decides the knight is a better occupant of the c4 outpost.
28.Nf4 Rc6
Defending e6 as well as clearing the c4 square and possibly preparing to add pressure down the c file with ...Rfc8.
29.Bf6+?
A serious misjudgment. The engines reckon White keeps an edge - "winning," according to Stockfish11, "slight," according to Komodo11 - with a move such as 29.a4.
29...Nxf6 30.exf6
How should Black proceed?
30...Nc4
Did Reshevsky miss this simple zwischenzug? White is massively better after 30...Qxf6? 31.Rge3, but 30...Nc4 scuppers Reshevsky's plans.
31.Qb1 Qxf6
The net result of 29.Bf6+? is that White has lost a pawn and exchanged an active bishop for an inactive knight.
32.a4 g5
Botvinnik seizes the initiative on the kingside while the white pieces are uncoordinated.
33.Nd3 f4 34.Rh3 g4 35.Rh1 Rc7 36.Qd1 Qg6 37.Rh4 f3 38.g3
Reshevsky has been able to close lines on the kingside, but his forces remain uncoordinated. His one plus is pressure against the weak e pawn.
38...Rcf7?
Abandoning the c file lets White off the hook. The engines reckon Black keeps an edge with 38...Rfc8 or 38...Rf6.
39.Nf4?
Walking into a simple and very strong exchange sac. The position seems equal after 39.Ne5 Nxe5 40.Rxe5, White's giving up the c file meaning he cannot reply 40...Rxc3.
39...Rxf4! 40.gxf4 Rxf4
Black has two pawns and a powerful attack for the exchange.
41.Qb1
This is best, according to the engines, but White is already busted.
41...Rf5 42.Qd3
The engines give 42.Re4 or 42.Kh2 as best but in each case a simple answer is 42...Nd2.
42...g3 43.Qf1 gxf2+ 44.Kxf2 Rg5 45.Qh3 Rg2+ 46.Kf3 Nd2+ 47.Ke3 Rg3+ 0-1
*The move-count was one less in Kasparov-Short, but the game reached the same position as in Reshevsky-Botvinnik.

Saturday, 12 September 2020

Champion Of Champions (part 15)

HERE is the tournament bracket ahead of the final.

Round of 16               Quarter-Finals          Semi-Finals                      Final
1. Steinitz
v----------------------------Carlsen
16. Carlsen (+102.5)
                                    v................................Tal
8.Tal (+8.5)
v----------------------------Tal (+79.5)
9.Petrosian
                                                                      v.....................................Botvinnik
6. Botvinnik (+66)
v----------------------------Botvinnik (+18.5)
11. Fischer
                                    v.................................Botvinnik (+406.5)
13. Kasparov
v----------------------------Alekhine
4. Alekhine (+21.5)
                                                                                                             v...........................
3. Capablanca
v----------------------------Kramnik (+118)
14. Kramnik (+12)
                                     v................................Kramnik (+13)
5. Euwe
v----------------------------Karpov
12. Karpov (+11.5)
                                                                       v.....................................Kramnik
7. Smyslov (+18)
v----------------------------Smyslov (+11.5)
10. Spassky
                                     v................................Smyslov
15. Anand
v----------------------------Lasker
2. Lasker (+50.5)

Botvinnik reached the final by beating Fischer, Alekhine and Tal; Kramnik reached the final by beating Capablanca, Karpov and Smyslov.
Who had the tougher route? Hard to say, but Botvinnik's margins of victory were, in general, more convincing.

Final
Game One
Mkikhail Botvinnik - Vladimir Kramnik
Nimzo-Indian
1.d4 Nf6 2.c4 e6 3.Nc3 Bb4 4.e3 0-0 5.Bd3 c5
Kramnik has played this eight times in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database, compared with five times for 5...d5.
6.a3
This is as far as we can go as Kramnik has not faced 6.a3
The analysis engines Stockfish11 and Komodo11.01 are divided over this position, with the former liking Black but the latter narrowly preferring White.
Their averaged evaluations give Kramnik a score of +25.5 - a commanding position since he has the white pieces to come.

Game Two
Vladimir Kramnik - Mikhail Botvinnik
Queen's Indian
1.d4 Nf6 2.c4 e6 3.Nf3 b6 4.g3 Bb7 5.Bg2 Be7 6.0-0 0-0 7.Re1 d5 8.cxd5
As far as we can go - Botvinnik did not face 8.cxd5
The engines give White an averaged advantage of +11.
Here is the final tournament bracket.

Round of 16               Quarter-Finals          Semi-Finals                      Final
1. Steinitz
v----------------------------Carlsen
16. Carlsen (+102.5)
                                    v................................Tal
8.Tal (+8.5)
v----------------------------Tal (+79.5)
9.Petrosian
                                                                      v.....................................Botvinnik
6. Botvinnik (+66)
v----------------------------Botvinnik (+18.5)
11. Fischer
                                    v.................................Botvinnik (+406.5)
13. Kasparov
v----------------------------Alekhine
4. Alekhine (+21.5)
                                                                                                             v.............................Kramnik
3. Capablanca
v----------------------------Kramnik (+118)
14. Kramnik (+12)
                                     v................................Kramnik (+13)
5. Euwe
v----------------------------Karpov
12. Karpov (+11.5)
                                                                       v.....................................Kramnik (+36.5)
7. Smyslov (+18)
v----------------------------Smyslov (+11.5)
10. Spassky
                                     v................................Smyslov
15. Anand
v----------------------------Lasker
2. Lasker (+50.5)

The Champion Of Champions: Vladimir Kramnik.

Thursday, 10 September 2020

Champion Of Champions (part 13)

HERE is the updated tournament bracket ahead of the semi-finals.

Round of 16               Quarter-Finals          Semi-Finals               Final
1. Steinitz
v----------------------------Carlsen
16. Carlsen (+102.5)
                                    v................................Tal
8.Tal (+8.5)
v----------------------------Tal (+79.5)
9.Petrosian
                                                                      v...............................
6. Botvinnik (+66)
v----------------------------Botvinnik (+18.5)
11. Fischer
                                    v.................................Botvinnik
13. Kasparov
v----------------------------Alekhine
4. Alekhine (+21.5)

3. Capablanca
v----------------------------Kramnik (+118)
14. Kramnik (+12)
                                     v................................Kramnik
5. Euwe
v----------------------------Karpov
12. Karpov (+11.5)
                                                                       v...............................
7. Smyslov (+18)
v----------------------------Smyslov (+11.5)
10. Spassky
                                     v................................Smyslov
15. Anand
v----------------------------Lasker
2. Lasker (+50.5)

Semi-Finals
Match One: Tal v Botvinnik
Game One
Mikhail Tal - Mikhail Botvinnik
French Tarrasch
1.e4 e6 2.d4 d5 3.Nd2
As noted in part two of this series. when Tal 'played' Petrosian, there are 49 examples of Tal choosing 3.Nd2 in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database, compared with 46 examples of the arguably more Tal-like 3.Nc3.
3...c5 4.Ngf3 Nc6
Botvinnik played this once and 4...a6 once, but lost with the latter and won with the former, so 4...Nc6 is chosen on tiebreak.
5.exd5
Tal played this and 7.Bb5 seven times each, in both cases scoring 79%, but his rating performance was much better with the text.
5...exd5 6.Bb5 cxd4
Botvinnik played this and 6...Bd6 twice each, scoring 50% with the latter but a win and a draw with the text.
Tal did not face 6...cxd4, so this is as far as we can go
The analysis engines Stockfish11 and Komodo11.01 give Tal an averaged advantage of +52.5 - a large score for Botvinnik to overcome.

Game Two
Mikhail Botvinnik - Mikhail Tal
Nimzo-Indian
1.d4 Nf6 2.c4 e6 3.Nc3 Bb4
There are 81 games in Mega20 in which Tal played the text, compared with 10 for 3...c5. He scored much better with the latter, but moves are chosen for 'games' in Champion Of Champions by popularity, not success.
4.e3 0-0 5.Bd3 d5 6.a3 dxc4 7.Bxc4 Bd6 8.Nf3 Nc6 9.b4 e5 10.Bb2 Bg4 11.d5
Botvinnik played the text and 11.dxe5 once each, drawing with the latter but winning with 11.d5.
11...Ne7 12.h3 Bd7 13.Ng5 Ng6 14.Ne6 fxe6 15.dxe6 Kh8 16.exd7 Qxd7 17.0-0 Qf5 18.Nd5 Ng8 19.Qg4 Qc2 20.Qe2 Qf5 21.Qg4 Qc2 22.Qe2 Qf5 23.e4 Qd7 24.Rad1 Rad8 25.Qg4 Qe8 26.g3 Nh6 27.Qh5 Ng8 28.Qe2 N6e7 29.Ne3 Nh6 30.Ng4 Nxg4 31.hxg4 Nc6 32.Kg2 Be7 33.Bd5 Nd4 34.Bxd4 exd4 35.Bc4 c5 36.b5 Bf6 37.f4 d3 38.Rxd3 Rxd3 39.Bxd3 Bd4 40.e5 g6 41.Rh1 Kg7 42.Qe4 b6 43.Bc4
We have reached the final position - Tal resigned here - of  the third game from the Botvinnik-Tal world championship match of 1961
The engines give White an averaged advantage of +459, meaning Botvinnik has well and truly overcome his 52.5 deficit from game one.
Here is the updated tournament bracket.

Round of 16               Quarter-Finals          Semi-Finals                      Final
1. Steinitz
v----------------------------Carlsen
16. Carlsen (+102.5)
                                    v................................Tal
8.Tal (+8.5)
v----------------------------Tal (+79.5)
9.Petrosian
                                                                      v.....................................Botvinnik
6. Botvinnik (+66)
v----------------------------Botvinnik (+18.5)
11. Fischer
                                    v.................................Botvinnik (+406.5)
13. Kasparov
v----------------------------Alekhine
4. Alekhine (+21.5)

3. Capablanca
v----------------------------Kramnik (+118)
14. Kramnik (+12)
                                     v................................Kramnik
5. Euwe
v----------------------------Karpov
12. Karpov (+11.5)
                                                                       v...............................
7. Smyslov (+18)
v----------------------------Smyslov (+11.5)
10. Spassky
                                     v................................Smyslov
15. Anand
v----------------------------Lasker
2. Lasker (+50.5)

Wednesday, 15 July 2020

Champion Repertoire (part six)

MIKHAIL Botvinnik won the world championship THREE times, a record that will be hard to beat.*
A repertoire based on Botvinnik's games in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database is the first in this series not to feature open  games - Botvinnik preferred 1.d4 as White and most-often met 1.e4 with 1...e6.
White
Play 1.d4 with the aim of reaching a Rubinstein Nimzo-Indian: 1...Nf6 2.c4 e6 3.Nc3 Bb4 4.e3. Against the main reply 4...0-0 Botvinnik scored 78% with 5.Bd3, rising to 82% after 5...d5 6.a3. Similarly he scored 83% with 5...c5 6.a3.
Against 4...c5 he scored 90% with 5.Nge2, and used the same move to score 75% against 5...b6.
Against 4...d5 Botvinnik scored 90% with 5.a3.
Against the King's Indian: 1...Nf6 2.c4 g6 3.Nc3 Bg7 4.e4 d6 his chief weapon was the Sämisch: 5.f3. In the main line 5...0-0 6.Be3 e5 he scored 79% with 7.d5, rising to 83% after 7...c6 8.Nge2!?Against 6...Nc6 he favoured 7.Nge2.
Against the Grünfeld: 3...d5 he scored 71% with the Russian System: 4.Nf3 Bg7 5.Qb3. After the mainline continuation 5...dxc4 6.Qxc4 0-0 7.e4 the move he faced most often was 7...Bg4, against which he scored 63% with 8.Be3. Botvinnik's games in Mega20 do bot include today's favourites 7...a6 and 7...Nc6.
In the Queen's Gambit Declined: 1...d5 2.c4 e6 3.Nc3 Nf6 he usually continued 4.Nf3, quite often reversing the last two moves.
Against 4...Be7 he generally continued 5.Bg5, but on reaching the tabiya arising after 5...0-0 6.e3 Nbd7 he rejected Rc1 in favour of 7.Bd3!? The idea is that after the continuation 7...dxc4 8.Bxc4 c5 9.0-0 cxd4 10.exd4 Nb6 White can drop his light-square bishop back to b3 with dangerous attacking chances (see below for Botvinnik's demolition of Milan Vidmar at Nottingham 1936).
In the Slav: 2...c6 Botvinnik scored 86% with the mainline 3.Nf3 Nf6 4.e3 e6 5.Nc3 Nbd7 6.Bd3 dxc4 7.Bxc4 b5 8.Bd3.
He only faced 4...Bf5 once, winning with the somewhat unusual, but it has since been played by Karpov, Korchnoi and Kasparov, 5.Bd3!? Bxd3 6.Qxd3.
Against the Queen's Gambit Accepted: 2...dxc4 he scored 67% with another unusual line, 3.Nf3 Nf6 4.Qa4+. The main line continues 4...c6 5.Qxc4 when White has good central control, and it does not prove easy for Black to successfully harass the white queen, for example the direct 5...Be6?! is considered doubtful because after 6.Qc2 g6 7.e4 Black is in danger of being overrun in the centre.
Black v 1.e4
Botvinnik scored 65% with the French Winawer: 1...e6 2.d4 d5 3.Nc3 Bb4, rising to 79% in the mainline 4.e5 c5 5.a3 Bxc3+ 6.bxc3 Ne7. Most of Botvinnik's opponents continued 7.Nf3, which he generally met with 7...Nbc6 8.a4 Bd7.
Perhaps surprisingly he only faced 7.Qg4 three times, at least according to Mega20, so it is difficult to give a repertoire recommendation but, for what it is worth, Botvinnik drew the one time he replied 7...Nf5 and scored a win and a loss with 7...cxd4.
A popular reply to the Winawer in Botvinnik's time was another line with Qg4, the sharp 4.a3 Bxc3+ 5.bxc3 dxe4 6.Qg4 Nf6 7.Qxg7 Rg8 8.Qh6 c5 9.Ne2, which he faced six times, scoring two wins and a draw with 9...Nc6.
Against the French Tarrasch: 3.Nd2 he scored 61% with 3...c5 in 14 games and 64% with 3...Nf6 in seven games, which makes it something of a toss-up from a repertoire viewpoint.
Against the Advance Variation: 3.e5 he scored 90% with the orthodox 5...c5.
He only faced the King's Indian Attack: 2.d3/Qe2 four times, but always went for an initial Sicilian set-up with 2...c5.
Black v 1.d4 and Others
Aim for a Nimxo-Indian: 1...Nf6 2.c4 e6 3.Nc3 Bb4, after which Botvinnik scored 70% when meeting 4.e3 with 4...c5.
Against 4.Qc2, the most-popular continuation in his career, he scored 62% with 4...d5, generally replying to 5.cxd5 with 5...exd5.
Against 4.Nf3 he did best with 4...b6, and against 4.a3 Bxc3+ 5.bxc3 he played 5...c5.
The only other game in Mega20 featured 4.Qb3, which he met with 4...c5.
If White avoided the Nimzo-Indian by playing 3.Nf3, Botvinnik usually played the Queen's Indian: 3...b6, generally playing the main lines that follow 4.g3 Bb7 5.Bg2 Be7 6.0-0 0-0 7.Nc3 Ne4.
He faced 4.e3 and 4.Nc3 twice each, always playing 4...Bb7. However, thanks to a transposition, he reached the position after 4.Nc3 Bb7 5.Bg5 four times, doing best with 5...Be7.
Against 2.Nf3 Botvinnik scored 82% with the move that Alekhine was also very successful with, 2...b6.
Botvinnik varied against the English: 1.c4 but his most-popular reply was 1...Nf6, winning all three games that continued 2.Nc3 c5, and scoring 70% with 2.Nf3 c5. He only faced 2.g3 twice, drawing with 2...c6 3.Bg2 d5, but winning with 2...e5 3.Bg2 c6.
Against 1.Nf3 he liked 1...Nf6, transposing to English lines with 2.c4 c5, but generally copying White's moves after 2.g3, ie 2...g6 3.Bg2 Bg7 4.0-0 0-0. Four of the five games to reach this position saw 5.d3, which Botvinnik met three times with 5...c5 5.e4 Nc6.


Here is Botvinnik using his 7.Bd3!? weapon in the Queen's Gambit Declined.
Botvinnik - Milan Vidmar (Snr)
Nottingham 1936
1.c4 e6 2.Nf3 d5 3.d4 Nf6
Today this is generally considered a good move-order for Black since it avoids an Exchange Variation in which White has the option of Nge2.
4.Bg5 Be7 5.Nc3 0-0 6.e3 Nbd7 7.Bd3!?
As noted earlier the main move is 7.Rc1.
Position after 7.Bd3!?
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
7...c5!?
The main line goes 7...dxc4 8.Bxc4 c5 9.0-0, when Black usually chooses between 9...a6 and 9...cxd4. After the latter the game Steve Bolduc (2200) - Spanton (-), World Open (Philadelphia) 1993 continued 10.exd4 Nd5!? (10...Nb6 is normal) 11.Bxe7 Nxe7 12.Re1 Nf6 with a roughly level game (½–½, 38 moves).
8.0-0 cxd4 9.exd4 dxc4 10.Bxc4
The game has transposed to the main line, as in Bolduc - Spanton. Vidmar continues with the move that was Black's chief reply then and still is today
10...Nb6 11.Bb3 Bd7 12.Qd3!?
As played by Lasker in one of his 1894 world-championship wins against Steinitz. The main line today is considered to be 12.Ne5 although this scores five percentage points fewer in Mega20.
12...Nbd5
Steinitz played 12...Rc8, but there are no other examples of this move in Mega20
13.Ne5 Bc6 14.Rad1!?
The 'obvious' 14.Bxc6, winning the bishop-pair and giving Black two queenside isolanis, was tried in a 2005 Bundesliga game, Dennis Breder (2454) - Rafael Fridman (2427), but that was prematurely agreed drawn after 14...bxc6 15.Rfd1 Rb8. Botvinnik seems to have decided the knight on e5 is stronger than the bishop on c6, or at least that the opportunity to play Nxc6 is not going to disappear any time soon.
14...Nb4?!
Hitting the black queen, but this only encourages White to switch it to the kingside, and meanwhile the knight has no influence on what quickly becomes the critical sector of the board. The analysis engines Stockfish11 and Komodo11.01 reckon White is only slightly better after, for example, 14...Rc8.
15.Qh3 Bd5!?
This leads to an exchange of minor pieces, which is generally beneficial to the side playing against an IQP, but after ...
16.Nxd5 Nbxd5?! 17.f4
... White has a strong attack. The engines reckon better was 16...Nfxd5, but agree 17.Bxe7 Qxe7 18.f4 is promising for White.
17...Rc8 18.f5 exf5 19.Rxf5
Apart from the rook on d1, White is massing against the black kingside, the strength of his position being obvious from the engines' main continuation, which involves giving up the exchange with 19...Rc6!?
19...Qd6 20.Nxf7! Rxf7 21.Bxf6 Bxf6 22.Rxd5 Qc6 23.Rd6 Qe8 24.Rd7 1-0
*Botvinnik first became world champion in a five-player 1948 tournament held to find someone to replace the deceased former title holder, Alekhine. He lost the title to Smyslov in 1957, won it back in 1958, lost it again to Tal in 1960 and won it back for the last time in 1961.