Tuesday 25 August 2020

Best By Test (part five)

ONE of the most intriguing of the Sicilian statistics is the success of the Alapin, ie 2.c3.
Its percentage score of 49% is nothing special, although it equals the score of 2.Nc3 and is only two percentage points behind 2.Nf3.
But 2.c3's rating performance of +40 is well clear of the field, in particular leading 2.Nf3 by 19 points and 2.Nc3 by 27 points.
Here I want to look at 2.c3's success, from a statistical viewpoint, in its 2,662 appearances in games played last year in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database (I will ignore moves occurring less than one percent of the time).

Table 13: Popularity Of Black Moves After 1.e4 c5 2.c3
Move.....Number Of Times Played
2...Nf6....................979
2...d5......................947
2...d6......................211
2...e6......................181
2...g6......................164
2...Nc6.....................93
2...e5........................53

I am not surprised at the modern popularity of 2...Nf6 and 2...d5, but I was not expecting 2...e6 to be less popular than 2...d6.

Table 14: Black Second Moves By Percentage Score (tie broken by frequency of appearance)
Move....................Score
2...Nf6..................56%
2...d5....................51%
2...e5....................49%
2...d6....................46%
2...e6....................43%
2...g6....................43%
2...Nc6.................32%

What is interesting here is that the moves' percentage scores, with the exception of 2...e5, are in the same order as the number of times they are played.

Table 15: Black Second Moves By Rating Performance
Move.............Rating Performance
2...d5....................-20
2...e5....................-34
2...Nc6.................-38
2...Nf6..................-40
2...e6....................-65
2...g6....................-65
2...d6....................-75

Table 15 shakes things up, in particular with the poor performances of the third-and-fourth most-popular moves, 2...d6 and 2...e6.
The move 2...e5 confirms the relative success of its percentage score, but this is from a small sample size.
It is striking how poorly 2...g6 does, both percentage-wise and in rating performance.
(To be continued)

No comments:

Post a Comment