By contrast, my other main blog, 10mm and all that!, has 1,395,465 hits, and Chess Tip Of The Day, which is primarily a feeder for Beau Chess, and has been active for a much shorter time, has 32,058.
I begin this blog after getting back into league chess following many years' absence due to work. My post-job status also means I am able to play more tournament chess. My new club in London is Battersea and my first game for them is on Thursday September 14, 2017. I start with a Fide rating of 1858, an ECF grade of 169 (=1968 elo) and an ICCF correspondence rating of 2267. My current Fide is 1971, my ECF is 1955 and my ICCF is 2374.
Showing posts with label Statistics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Statistics. Show all posts
Friday, 6 November 2026
Seventh Heaven
BEAU Chess passed seven million views this morning, reaching - as I write - 7,076,262.
Tuesday, 3 November 2026
ECF v Fide
MY 'worst ever tournament', and the discussion it prompted, both at Beau Chess, and last week while talking to other players during the English championships at Peterborough, led to further discussion about my over-the-board elo ratings, both national (ECF) and international (Fide).
I am not sure what the graph proves, if anything, but it may be significant that my ECF rating, although fluctuating, has not moved about as much as my Fide rating.
My ratings have varied quite a lot since they became directly comparable in January 2021, which was when the English Chess Federation introduced four-digit ratings, replacing three-digit grades.
I have created the following graph, showing how my ratings have stood at each quarter, ie in January, April, July and October of the years 2021-6, using a handy tool at the US's National Center for Education Statistics.
![]() |
| Note that a large part of the rise in my Fide rating in early 2024 was due to a recalibration by Fide, designed to correct perceived deflation in the elos of players rated U2000 |
But even that impression is misleading, as the recalibration in early-2024 is responsible for a large chunk of the Fide rating fluctuation.
Take out the recalibration, and the green line does not vary significantly more than the red line, at least to my eyes.
The ECF's rating manager made an interesting observation yesterday at the English Chess Forum: "While there is great variation, a rule of thumb is that those over 60 on average lose 0.5 of an ECF rating point per game played."
I am 69, and I play roughly 70 ECF-rated games a year, which means my ECF rating should, on average, be falling 35 elo a year.
My annual total of Fide-rated games is roughly twice that number, so I guess my Fide rating should be falling some 70 elo a year.
[Note that there is some overlap, eg games at the British and English championships are rated for both the ECF and Fide.]
Fortunately, this decline does not seem to have happened, yet ...
Saturday, 31 October 2026
Six Of The Best
AT some point today, Beau Chess passed six million hits, the count standing (as I write) at 6,095,646, contrasting with 766,612 views for my other main blog, 10mm and all that!, and 31,334 for Chess Tip Of The Day, albeit the last-named has been running for a much shorter time, and is primarily intended as a feeder for Beau Chess.
Thursday, 24 September 2026
Lessons From Bad Bertrich VIII
MY round-eight game, in which I was White against Horst Prüsse (2006), began as an O'Kelly Variation in the Sicilian: 1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 a6.
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
All I could recall was that 3.d4!? was considered a mistake, and that White should play a line in which ...a6 would not prove useful, eg going into an Alapin setup with 3.c3.
I cannot recall where this advice came from, but in the end I rather went against it by playing 3.c4, intending to play a Maróczy Bind, even though ...a6 in the Maróczy is a common move as, among other things, it helps prepare the break ...b5.
Imagine my surprise when I discovered, after the game, 3.d4!? is easily the commonest continuation in ChessBase's 2026 Mega database (I also found that I had played 3.d4!? last year, albeit with the special intention of switching into a Morra Gambit).
So, was the advice in my mind simply wrong, or had I misremembered altogether? Maybe not, on both counts.
For starters, the top two recommendations of Stockfish18 and Dragon1 are 3.c4 and 3.c3, although the former engine comes to like 3.g3!? the more time it is given to consider the position.
And then there are the stats to consider. 3.c4 scores 56% in Mega26, 3.c3 scores 54% and even 3.g3!? scores 52%, whereas 3.d4!? turns in a miserable 40%.
The main line in Mega26, after 3.d4!?, runs 3...cxd4 4.Nxd4 Nf6 5.Nc3, and now Black gets to play what is effectively an Accelerated Najdorf, ie 5...e5!?
*****
*****
*****
*****
The engines agree Black has already at least equalised, eg after the main move in Mega26, 6.Nf3, they reckon 6...Bb4!? starts to tip the balance in Black's favour.
So it seems the half-remembered advice I had at the back of my mind was sound after all. But it would have been nice if I had originally spent some time learning the reasons behind the advice, rather than just noting it.
LESSON: as usual in chess, knowing something is good, but knowing why it is good is much better.
Monday, 17 August 2026
Three's A Charm
LATE yesterday Beau Chess passed the three-million hits mark, the total now standing at 3,007,310.
No doubt many of these views are by bots, although it is interesting that my other main blog, 10mm and all that!, which has been running slightly longer, has 'only' 198,377 hits, while Chess Tip Of The Day, which is a feeder blog for the web version of Beau Chess, has 20,254 hits, albeit over a much shorter period of time.
Wednesday, 22 April 2026
Millionaire!
Thursday, 25 March 2021
Knight v Bishop (conclusions)
THIS series has looked at bishop-v-knight endings from my praxis that had equal pawns but did not end in draws.
There were none with eight pawns aside, and only one with one pawn aside, but that has been ignored as it arose with a mate-in-two on the board.
Here are the results of the other cases.
Pawns Aside........Knight Wins.....Bishop Wins
Seven 9 8
Six 21 7
Five 7 6
Four 1 5
Three 3 0
Two 0 2
Total: 41 28
The general wisdom has it that a bishop is more likely to outplay a knight when there are fewer pawns on the board.
At a glance it might be thought the results of this series fly in the face of this argument in that the knight won 59.4% of the games.
But that is largely because 84.1% of the positions began with 10 or more pawns on the board.
The knight's winning percentage in positions with 10 or more pawns is 63.8, which is almost identical to the bishop's winning percentage of 63.6 in positions with eight or fewer pawns.
Now 69 games do not constitute a large sample, but they do support the general wisdom that the more pawns there are, the happier is the situation, other things being equal, of the player with the knight.
Tuesday, 29 December 2020
Garry Kasparov's Forgotten Weapon Against The Queen's Gambit
ANYONE who is happy, when having the black pieces, to play 1.d4 d5 2.c4 e6 faces something of a dilemma if White continues with the main move 3.Nc3.
Black then usually plays 3...Nf6, at which point the commonest move in ChessBase's 2021 Mega database is 4.Bg5, which scores 59%, ie about four percentage points above White's usual score in large databases.
But there is worse to come - White can play 4.cxd5, the Exchange Variation, which scores a phenomenal 65%, the usual continuation being 4...exd5 5.Bg5.
It is instructive to compare this with White's second-most popular continuation at move three, namely 3.Nf3.
After the further moves 3...Nf6 4.cxd5 exd5, White's score plummets to 50%.
In other words, statistically speaking, White has lost the advantage of having the first move.
In practice White more often follows up 3.Nf3 Nf6 with 4.Nc3.
Black then has a large choice of respectable replies, including 4...Be7, 4...c6, 4...Bb4, 4...Nbd7, 4...c5 and 4...dxc4, each of which occurs at least 5,000 times in Mega21.
Most popular is 4...Be7, when White can again enter the Exchange Variation, but by now 5.cxd5 exd5 6.Bg5 scores only 56%, falling to 52% if Black responds with 6...c6.
True, 56% is marginally higher than White's usual average across all openings, but it is a significant drop from the 65% of 3.Nc3 Nf6 4.cxd5.
One of the main reasons the Exchange Variation with 3.Nc3 scores so much better than with an early Nf3 is that the former allows White to play the king's knight to e2.
This opens new possibilities for White, including a central advance with f3 and e4, which can be particularly effective as White in the Exchange Variation has a 2-1 central pawn-majority.
Another reason is that Nf3 played too early lets Black render the Exchange Variation largely harmless by more-or-less forcing off light-square bishops, as the following ICCF correspondence game illustrates.
James Cairney (1983) - Spanton (unrated)
2nd British Webserver Team Tournament 2013
1.d4 d5 2.c4 e6 3.Nc3 Nf6 4.cxd5 exd5 5.Nf3!?
It would be over-the top to call this a mistake, but it scores just 45% in Mega21.
Black can now plan on playing ...Bf5, occupying the diagonal usually taken by the white light-square bishop.
5...c6
An immediate 5...Bf5!? may even be possible, the idea being that 6.Qb3 can be met by 6...Nc6 with sharp play.
6.Qc2
More popular is 6.Bg5, but Black can reply 6...Bf5, when 7.Qb3 Qb6 8.Bxf6 gxf6 is not considered particularly promising for White.
6...g6
My modern analysis engines, Stockfish12 and Komodo11.01, prefer a bishop move, eg 6...Be7, 6...Bd6 or 6...Bg4, but are fine with the text once shown it.
7.Bg5
Black is at least equal, and maybe even a tad better, after 7.e3 Bf5.
The text also sets a mini-positional trap that has snared grandmasters.
7...Bg7
The problem with 7...Bf5?! is that 8.Qb3 is awkward to meet since 8...Qb6?? is a gross blunder due to 9.Bxf6. Black's most-popular reply in Mega21 is 8...b6?, but 9.e4! dxe4 10.Ne5 Be6 11.Bc4 Qe7 12.d5 was catastrophic for Black in Péter Lukács (2460) - Jakab Attila (2396), Budapest GM-B 2002 (1-0, 15 moves). Black probably has nothing better than 8...Bc8, when 9.e4 is again strong.
Massively more popular than the text is 7...Be7, but 7...Bg7, which has been played by Euwe, Ragozin, Dreev and Negi, seems fine.
8.e3 Bf5 9.Bd3
Black is posed no problems by 9.Qb3 Qb6 10.Be2.
9...Bxd3 10.Qxd3 Nbd7 11.0-0
I see from my notes that two of my engines at the time, Stockfish3 and Houdini1.5a, reckoned White is slightly better, but Junior10 called the position equal. Today's engines, Stockfish12 and Komodo11.01, agree with Junior10.
11...0-0 12.Rfc1
White is preparing the dreaded Minority Attack, but, theoretically speaking, Black has nothing to fear here.
12...a5 13.Na4 Qe7 14.Bh4 Rfe8 15.a3 Qe6 16.Bxf6!?
This is Stockfish12's choice.
16...Bxf6 17.Qb3!?
The choice of both Stockfish12 and Komodo11.01, but it looks strange to me. Certainly, obstructing the b2 pawn does not help White's Minority Attack.
17...Ra7!?
This appears slightly awkward, but is a reasonably economical way of defending b7 and a5.
18.Nc3 Qf5 19.Rc2 g5!?
The classic black answer to a Minority Attack is to stabilise the queenside and counterattack on the other flank.
20.Re2 g4 21.Nd2 a4! 22.Qd1
22.Nxa4?! Bxd4.
22...Qg6 23.e4!
This central counterattack is also the choice of Stockfish12 and Komodo11.01.
23...Nb6
23...Bxd4 24.exd5 Rxe2 25.Qxe2 Bxc3 26.dxc6 bxc6 27.bxc3 was given by Houdini1.5a as equal, although Komodo11.01 - but not Stockfish12 - reckons White has a small edge.
24.exd5
Black seems fine after 24.e5 Bg5.
24...Rxe2 25.Qxe2 Nxd5
*****
*****
*****
*****
White has an IQP, which is blockaded by a black knight, but otherwise the white position is sound, and the black kingside attack has been stopped in its tracks. Black's pawns are a little loose and the black rook is passive and not coordinated with the other black pieces, but the bishop bears down on the d4 target. My modern engines reckon the position is equal, and I believe that was also the verdict of my engines seven years ago.
26.Rd1 Nxc3!?
This unisolates d4 but gives White another isolani at a3. It also lets Black play ...b5 to protect a4 without worrying about the c pawn being backward on a half-open file, simultaneously solving the difficulty of the out-of-play black rook. However, White gets an initiative.
27.bxc3 b5 28.Qe8+ Kg7 29.Re1
Not 29.Qxc6?? Qc2, but after the text the c6 pawn is threatened.
29...Bg5 30.Nf1 f5 31.Qc8 Re7
Forced, otherwise White has 32.Re6.
32.Rxe7 Bxe7
Queen and knight can make a better team than queen and bishop, but here the bishop has targets and the white queen and knight are widely separated. However, the black king is much the more exposed, and the engines agree the position is still level.
33.Qd7 Qf6 34.Ne3 Kf8
After the natural-looking 34...Kg6!?, White can cause problems with 35.d5, although it is not clear that White gets a substantial advantage.
35.Nxf5
But not 35.Qxf5?? Qxf5 36.Nxf5 Bxa3, and the a4 pawn is too strong.
35...Bxa3 36.Qc8+ Kf7 37.Qd7+ Kg6!?
37...Kf8 repeats the position. The text keeps the game going, with both players walking a tightrope.
38.Ng3 Bf8 39.Qxg4+ Kf7 40.Qd7+ Kg8 41.d5 a3 42.dxc6
White has won two pawns, but the a pawn is a monster that can promote with check. The game is still level, according to the engines.
42...Qd6 43.Qg4+?!
White can force a draw by 43.Nf1 Qxd7 (other moves lose) 44.cxd7 Be7 45.Nd2. The text may also draw, but is less clear, and is dodgy from a practical view as Black keeps his passed pawn while White will lose his, meaning White cannot realistically win.
43...Kh8 44.Qe2 Qxc6 45.Qe5+ Kg8 46.Qg5+ Qg6!?
Black can force a repetition with 46...Kh8, or try for more in another way with 46...Kf7 47.Qh5+ Qg6 48.Qf3+ Qf6. But after the latter it seems both 49.Qh5+ and 49.Qb7+ draw, eg 49.Qb7+ (during the game I thought this was the surer draw for White, but now I am not so certain) Be7 50.Qxb5 a2 51.Qa4 Qe6 52.Ne4! Qxe4 53.Qxa2+, when White has queen and four pawns versus queen, bishop and one pawn. My engines at the time reckoned Black has the upper hand, but I could see no way to create winning chances, and my modern engines agree.
47.Qxb5 a2
White has engineered a new passed pawn (two actually, including the f pawn) and restored his two-pawn advantage, but the black passer has reached seventh heaven. Stockfish12 and Komodo11.01 reckon the game is level.
48.Qc4+ Qf7 49.Qg4+ Kh8 50.Qd4+ Bg7 51.Qd8+ Qg8 52.Qa5 h6 53.h4
It is interesting that both players have time to make quiet pawn moves. 52...h6 creates a square for the black king at h7, while 53.h4 removes the possibility of a back-rank mate and lets the white king move up to h2 if Black threatens a back-rank check to support the a pawn promoting.
53...Qe6
For a long time Stockfish12 shows 53...Qb3 as winning, but after I play through the moves 54.Qa8+ Kh7 55.Qe4+ Kg8 56.Qa8+ it agrees with Komodo11.01 that the game is drawn, eg 56...Bf8 57.Kh2 Qa3 58.Qd5+ Kh8 59.Nf5 a1=Q 60.Qd4+ Kh7 61.Qd7+ Be7 62.Nxe7 Q1xc3 63.Nf5+ and White has a perpetual.
54.Kh2?!
Komodo11.01 reckons this draws, but that is far from clear, as will be seen. However, 54.Ne4!? probably does draw, assuming 54...Qxe4 55.Qxa2 does not give Black winning chances after 55...Qxh4 or 55...Bxc3, which does seem to the case (I presume White's drawing chances are enhanced by the black h pawn's queening square being the opposite colour to the black bishop).
54...Be5 55.Qa3 Kg7 56.Qa5 h5 57.Qa3?
This loses.
Komodo11.01 gives 57.Kg1, and if 57...Kg6, which I have in my notes, it continues 58.Qa4 (I only had 58.Kh2, which it seems is definitely winning for Black), after which Stockfish12 switches between various moves, all of which at one time or another it reckons win for Black, but Komodo11.01 always manages to defend valiantly, sometimes with an assist from Stockfish12. There are several lines in which White can allow Black a second queen but still draw with perpetual check.
57...Bc7 0-1
Best-play seems to be something like 58.Qa8 (58.Qa4 Qd5 transposes) Qg8 59.Qa4 Qd5 60.f4 Kf8 (the king heads to the queenside for shelter!) 61.Qa3+ Ke8 62.Qa4+ Kd8 63.Qa3 Bxf4 (or 63.Ne2 Qa5 64.Qd1+ Kc8 65.Qa1 Qa4 66.c4 Qc2 67.Qh8+ Kb7 etc) 64.Qf8+ Kd7 65.Qg7+ Kc6 66.Qg6+ Kc5 67.Qa6 Bxg3+ 68.Kg3 Qd6+ etc.
White can make it an Exchange Variation as early as move three, but this approach is innocuous too.
Wolfgang Vullhorst (1820) - Spanton (2034)
Bad Wörishofen 20071.d4 d5 2.c4 e6 3.cxd5 exd5 4.Nc3 c6
The immediate 4...Bf5!? may be playable, intending to meet 5.Qb3 with 5...Nc6.
5.Qc2 g6 6.Bf4
This is the normal move in the position, but maybe White should try 6.e4!?, although it involves accepting an IQP that is already under restraint.
6...Bd6
I rejected 6...Bf5 because I wanted to oppose the active white bishop, and 6...Bf5 7.Qb3 more-or-less obliges Black to play ...Qb6, ruling out a quick ...Bd6. Nevertheless, 6...Bf5 is the main line.
7.Bxd6 Qxd6 8.e3
8.e4 dxe4 9.Nxe4 Qe7 is at least equal and may be a tad better for Black, according to Stockfish12 and Komodo11.01.
8...Bf5 9.Bd3 Ne7 10.Bxf5 Nxf5 11.Nf3 Nd7 12.b4
WV offered a draw.
12...0-0 13.Qb3
13.b5 cxb5 14.Nxb5?! Qb4 15.Nc3 Rfc8 is good for Black, although the engines reckon 14.Qb3 keeps the game equal.
13...b5!
This is a common positional ploy in the Exchange Variation when White no longer has a light-square bishop. White's Minority Attack is halted, and Black creates an outpost at c4 that, if needed, can be occupied by a knight, thus covering the newly backward c pawn.
14.0-0 a5 15.a3 Qe7 16.bxa5!? Rxa5 17.Qb4?
17.a4 keeps White's disadvantage to a minimum.
17...Rfa8 18.Rac1!?
The engines reckon 18.Qxe7 Nxe7 19.Nb1 is objectively better, but it is horribly passive.
18...Rxa3
Black is a protected passed pawn up and has the more-active rooks. I went on to win (although only after blundering my advantage away and having to, in effect, win the game a second time).
So what has all this to do with Garry Kasparov? That is what I will come to in part two of this series.
Labels:
Central pawn-majority,
ChessBase,
Houdini1.5a,
IQP,
Isolani,
Junior10,
Kasparov,
Komodo11.01,
Mega database,
Minority Attack,
QGD,
QGD Exchange Variation,
Statistics,
Stockfish12,
Stockfish3
Thursday, 3 December 2020
Belgrade Summary
MY final score at the 34th Belgrade Trophy International of +3*=2-4 saw me lose 17.4 Fide elo.
Full results, games and a few photos can be found at chess-results.com/tnr539344.aspx?lan=1
*My wins included one over an unrated.
Tuesday, 24 November 2020
Belgrade Stats Update
LOOKS like quite a few people left it to almost the last moment to enter
Federation statistics
| No. | FED | Federation | Count | |
| 1 | BIH | Bosnia & Herzegovina | 1 | |
| 2 | ENG | England | 1 | |
| 3 | MKD | Republic of North Macedonia | 2 | |
| 4 | MNE | Montenegro | 2 | |
| 5 | RUS | Russia | 7 | |
| 6 | SRB | Serbia | 45 | |
| 7 | SWE | Sweden | 2 | |
| 8 | TUR | Turkey | 1 | |
| Total | 61 |
Title statistics
| Title | Count |
| GM | 9 |
| WGM | 1 |
| IM | 5 |
| FM | 7 |
| Total | 22 |
Monday, 24 August 2020
Best By Test (part four)
CONCENTRATING for the moment on 1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 it is interesting to see the popularity of Black's second-move choices in modern chess.
As usual I am statistically analysing from the 238,275 games played in 2019 that appear in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database, while ignoring those moves that appear less than 0.1% of the time.
There are 34,594 games that began 1.e4 c5 2.Nf3, so the cut-off point is 35 games.
Table 10: Popularity Of Black Moves After 1.e4 c5 2.Nf3
Move.....Number Of Times Played
2...d6....................13,952
2...Nc6...................9,649
2...e6......................8,246
2...g6......................1,806
2...a6.........................693
2...Nf6......................268
2...b6..........................42
The big three should surprise no one, and I expect most people will have expected them to appear in the order shown.
Table 11: Black Second Moves By Percentage Score (ties broken by frequency of appearance)
Move...................Score
2...b6....................58%
2...a6....................54%
2...e6....................50%
2...d6....................49%
2...Nc6.................49%
2...Nf6..................48%
2...g6....................46%
The success of the relatively unpopular moves, 2...a6 and especially 2...b6, is a major surprise, but as usual this may change when moves are ranked by rating performance.
Table 12: Black Second Moves By Rating Performance
Move..........Rating Performance
2...g6......................-9
2...b6......................-15
2...d6......................-16
2...e6......................-23
2...Nc6...................-25
2...Nf6....................-26
2...a6......................-43
So 2...b6 confirms its success, but 2...a6 collapses. The other big mover is 2...g6 - bottom percentage-wise but top in rating performance.
There is a big caveat with 2...b6, however - the statistics are based on just 42 games.
Friday, 21 August 2020
Best By Test
ONE of world champion Bobby Fischer's most famous quotes is that 1.e4 is "best by test."
His view would likely have been supported by the great majority of 19th-century players.
But there have been times when 1.e4 has been out of favour, especially among the world's elite.
It was interesting to note in my Champion Repertoire series how the different world champions opened their games with the white pieces.
Fischer made his remark long before the advent of chess databases and engines.
It is pointless asking engines which is the best first move - their opening evaluations are very unsophisticated and there are just too many variables for them to come up with a useful verdict.
Databases, however, can give answers, at least from the viewpoints of popularity and statistical success.
So with the help of ChessBase's 2020 Mega database it is possible to discover what in modern chess is "best by test."
There are 238,275 games from 2019, which is the most-recent year available in Mega20.
In those games White scored 94,216 wins, 66,220 draws and 77,824 losses (+94,216=66,220-77,824). That is an overall score of 53%.
To make sure 2019 was not an exceptional year, I did the same search for the two years 2018-19 and the five years 2015-19. In both cases White scored 53%.
So it can be said with a reasonable degree of confidence that the 238,275 games from 2019 in Mega20 are a fair reflection of modern chess, at least in those events important enough to have their scores collected.
In those games the white players had an average rating of 2046 and scored a performance rating of 2057, ie +11.
Chess success can be measured statistically by percentage score and rating performance.
It is important to use both measures, even over a large sample such as 238,275, as percentage scores alone may be skewed by strong players being more likely on the white or black side of a particular opening variation.
There are 20 ways in which White can open a game (16 pawn moves and four knight moves), and all of them were played in 2019!
However some were played so infrequently (1.f3 occurs four times, 1.Na3 twice) that they can be excluded as statistically insignificant.
I decided that for a move to appear in table one below, it had to occur in at least 0.1% of games.
Table One: Openings By Popularity
Move.......Number of times played
1.e4......................114,450
1.d4........................79,279
1.Nf3.......................21,713
1.c4.........................16,456
1.b3..........................1,513
1.g3..........................1,323
1.f4...........................1,222
1.b4.............................425
1.Nc3..........................373
As can be seen, 1.e4 is by far the most-popular first move - it has many more appearances than the next two most-popular moves (1.d4 and 1.Nf3) combined.
Slightly surprising, at least to me, is how 1.Nf3 easily beats 1.c4 for third place. I suspect this is partly because 1.Nf3 is often used as a wait-and-see transpositional device that is considered more flexible than 1.c4.
The picture in table two, which shows White's opening moves by their percentage success, is very different.
Two fairly non-forcing kingside moves, 1.Nf3 and 1.g3, lead the way, with 1.e4 not doing all that much better, statistically speaking, than equality.
But at least 1.e4 does not give Black an edge, as 1.b4 appears to do with its score of 46%.
Table Two: Openings By Percentage Score (ties broken by frequency of appearance)
Move.........Score
1.Nf3..........57%
1.g3............57%
1.Nc3.........56%
1.c4............55%
1.d4............54%
1.e4............52%
1.b3............52%
1.f4.............50%
1.b4............46%
But, as I warned, it is dangerous to read percentage scores in isolation.
A very different picture emerges in table three, which lists White's opening moves according to how the players performed rating-wise.
Table Three: Openings By Rating Performance
Move..........Rating Performance
1.d4.....................+26
1.e4.....................+20
1.c4.....................+14
1.Nf3...................+11
1.b4.....................+6
1.f4......................+4
1.b3.....................+2
1.Nc3...................-17
1.g3.....................-23
White's most-popular moves, 1.e4 and 1.d4, lead the way, although "best by test," contra Fischer, is 1.d4.
Note that with 1.c4 claiming third spot, it could be said that it is the most-active moves, in the sense of moves that restrict Black's replies, which come out on top.
And look how badly 1.Nc3 and 1.g3 do - a complete reversal of looking at those moves by percentage score alone.
As an early conclusion we can say 1.e4 performs very well, but why does it lag six percentage points behind 1.d4?
(To be continued)
His view would likely have been supported by the great majority of 19th-century players.
But there have been times when 1.e4 has been out of favour, especially among the world's elite.
It was interesting to note in my Champion Repertoire series how the different world champions opened their games with the white pieces.
Fischer made his remark long before the advent of chess databases and engines.
It is pointless asking engines which is the best first move - their opening evaluations are very unsophisticated and there are just too many variables for them to come up with a useful verdict.
Databases, however, can give answers, at least from the viewpoints of popularity and statistical success.
So with the help of ChessBase's 2020 Mega database it is possible to discover what in modern chess is "best by test."
There are 238,275 games from 2019, which is the most-recent year available in Mega20.
In those games White scored 94,216 wins, 66,220 draws and 77,824 losses (+94,216=66,220-77,824). That is an overall score of 53%.
To make sure 2019 was not an exceptional year, I did the same search for the two years 2018-19 and the five years 2015-19. In both cases White scored 53%.
So it can be said with a reasonable degree of confidence that the 238,275 games from 2019 in Mega20 are a fair reflection of modern chess, at least in those events important enough to have their scores collected.
In those games the white players had an average rating of 2046 and scored a performance rating of 2057, ie +11.
Chess success can be measured statistically by percentage score and rating performance.
It is important to use both measures, even over a large sample such as 238,275, as percentage scores alone may be skewed by strong players being more likely on the white or black side of a particular opening variation.
There are 20 ways in which White can open a game (16 pawn moves and four knight moves), and all of them were played in 2019!
However some were played so infrequently (1.f3 occurs four times, 1.Na3 twice) that they can be excluded as statistically insignificant.
I decided that for a move to appear in table one below, it had to occur in at least 0.1% of games.
Table One: Openings By Popularity
Move.......Number of times played
1.e4......................114,450
1.d4........................79,279
1.Nf3.......................21,713
1.c4.........................16,456
1.b3..........................1,513
1.g3..........................1,323
1.f4...........................1,222
1.b4.............................425
1.Nc3..........................373
As can be seen, 1.e4 is by far the most-popular first move - it has many more appearances than the next two most-popular moves (1.d4 and 1.Nf3) combined.
Slightly surprising, at least to me, is how 1.Nf3 easily beats 1.c4 for third place. I suspect this is partly because 1.Nf3 is often used as a wait-and-see transpositional device that is considered more flexible than 1.c4.
The picture in table two, which shows White's opening moves by their percentage success, is very different.
Two fairly non-forcing kingside moves, 1.Nf3 and 1.g3, lead the way, with 1.e4 not doing all that much better, statistically speaking, than equality.
But at least 1.e4 does not give Black an edge, as 1.b4 appears to do with its score of 46%.
Table Two: Openings By Percentage Score (ties broken by frequency of appearance)
Move.........Score
1.Nf3..........57%
1.g3............57%
1.Nc3.........56%
1.c4............55%
1.d4............54%
1.e4............52%
1.b3............52%
1.f4.............50%
1.b4............46%
But, as I warned, it is dangerous to read percentage scores in isolation.
A very different picture emerges in table three, which lists White's opening moves according to how the players performed rating-wise.
Table Three: Openings By Rating Performance
Move..........Rating Performance
1.d4.....................+26
1.e4.....................+20
1.c4.....................+14
1.Nf3...................+11
1.b4.....................+6
1.f4......................+4
1.b3.....................+2
1.Nc3...................-17
1.g3.....................-23
White's most-popular moves, 1.e4 and 1.d4, lead the way, although "best by test," contra Fischer, is 1.d4.
Note that with 1.c4 claiming third spot, it could be said that it is the most-active moves, in the sense of moves that restrict Black's replies, which come out on top.
And look how badly 1.Nc3 and 1.g3 do - a complete reversal of looking at those moves by percentage score alone.
As an early conclusion we can say 1.e4 performs very well, but why does it lag six percentage points behind 1.d4?
(To be continued)
Friday, 28 February 2020
Long-Term Dragon Sac
PLAYED on board three (of 10) for Battersea 2 away to Cavendish 2 in division two of the London League last night.
Spanton (170) - Daniel Wright (187)
Sicilian Accelerated Dragon
1.e4 c5 2.Nc3 g6 3.Nf3 Bg7 4.d4 cxd4 5.Nxd4 Nc6 6.Nxc6!?
The normal move is 6.Be3.
6...bxc6 7.Bc4 d6 8.0-0
8.Qf3!? Nf6 9.e5 dxe5 10.Qxc6+ Bd7 is unclear.
8...Nf6 9.e5!? dxe5 10.Qxd8+ Kxd8 11.Re1
Not 11.Bxf7?? e6.
11...e6 12.Bg5 Kc7 13.Rad1 h6 14.Bh4
Stockfish10 and Komodo10 prefer 14.Bd2.
14...Nd5 15.Na4
15.Ne4?? loses a piece after 15...f5.
15...Nb6 16.Bb3 Nxa4 17.Bxa4 f6 18.Re3 Bb7
Stockfish10's choice. Komodo10 gives 18...g5 19.Bxc6!? Rb8 (if 19...Kxc6, then 20.Rc3+, when the black king cannot escape checks from the white king's rook) 20.Rc3 Rxb2 21.f3!? Kb8 22.Bf2 with compensation for a pawn.
19.f4 g5?
Apparently missing one of the points behind 19.f4, but White also has good compensation for a pawn after 19...exf4 20.Rxe6 Rhe8 21.Rde1 Rxe6 22.Rxe6 Kd7 23.Bb3, according to the engines.
20.fxg5
Better it seems is the engines' 20.Be1! as after 20...a5 21.Red3 Bc8 White can give Black doubled isolanis with 22.fxe5 fxe5.
20...hxg5 21.Be1 a5 22.Red3 Bc8 23.Rc3
Cavendish's Daire McMahon later suggested 23.Rd6 Ra6 24.R1d3?
I believe I was worried about 24...Bf8, when 25.Bxa5+ (only move) Rxa5 26.Rxc6+ Kb8 27.Rd8 Bc5+ 28.Rxc5 Rxd8 29.Rxa5 Bb7 slightly favours Black, according to the engines, despite White being a pawn up. The point seems to be that White's pieces are a little uncoordinated.
However, the engines give 24...e4 25.Bxa5+ Rxa5 26.Rxc6+ Kb8 27.Rb3+ Ka8 with a winning advantage for Black. If 25.Rd1, then f5 with a large advantage for Black, eg 26.c3 Be5 27.R6d2 Bxh2+.
23...Bb7 24.Rc5 Kb6 25.Bf2 Kc7 26.Be1 Kb6
With hindsight, Black should give back the pawn with 26...Bf8 27.Rxa5, when Komodo10 reckons the position is equal but Stockfish10 slightly prefers Black.
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
27.Rd7!!
This wins in all lines.
27...Bf8
If 27...Kxc5, then 28.Bf2+ Kb4 (or 28...Kc4 29.Bb3+ Kb5 30.a4+ Ka6 31.Bc4#) 29.Rxb7+ Kxa4 (if 29...Kc4, then 30.Bb3# ) 30.Bc5, and mate follows.
Or 27...Rhd8 28.Bf2! (28.Rxg7 Kxc5 29.Rxb7 is also strong) Ka6 (28...Rxd7? 29.Rxc6#), eg 29.Bxc6 Rxd7 30.Bxd7 Bf8 31.Rc7 Rd8 32.a4.
28.Rc3 Bc5+
If 28...Bb4, then 29.Bf2+ Ka6 30.Bxc6! Bxc3 31.Bxb7+ Kb5 32.Bxa8.
29.Rxc5! Kxc5 30.Bf2+ Kb4 31.Rxb7+ Kxa4
31...Kc4 32.Bb3#.
32.Bc5 1-0
Cavendish 2 won the match 8-2.
My updated Battersea statistics for 2019-20
Event*..Colour...Grade...Opponent's Grade...Result
CLL..…...B....…..168...………169...……….....W
CLL...…..B...…...168...………196...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………176...…………..L
LL....……W...…..168...…....…175...………….D
CLL...…..B...…...168...………192...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………181...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..168...………168...…………..L
EC...…….B...…..168...………175...……….….L
CLL...…...B.........170...………172...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..170...………183...…………..D
LL............W........170...…........180......……......L
LL....…….B...…..170....……...182...………….W
CLL...…...B...…..170...………183...……….….D
LL...……..B...…..170...………162...…………..W
LL...…….W...…..170...………172...…………..W
LL...…….W...…..170...………152...…………..L
CLL...…...B.........170..............194...................L
LL...…….W...…..170...….…...187...………….W
Overall this season for Battersea I have scored +5=5-8 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2018-19 I scored +12=12-13 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2017-18 I scored +10=8-9 for a grading performance of 175.
*CLL: Central London League; LL: London League; EC: Eastman Cup.
Spanton (170) - Daniel Wright (187)
Sicilian Accelerated Dragon
1.e4 c5 2.Nc3 g6 3.Nf3 Bg7 4.d4 cxd4 5.Nxd4 Nc6 6.Nxc6!?
The normal move is 6.Be3.
6...bxc6 7.Bc4 d6 8.0-0
8.Qf3!? Nf6 9.e5 dxe5 10.Qxc6+ Bd7 is unclear.
8...Nf6 9.e5!? dxe5 10.Qxd8+ Kxd8 11.Re1
Not 11.Bxf7?? e6.
11...e6 12.Bg5 Kc7 13.Rad1 h6 14.Bh4
Stockfish10 and Komodo10 prefer 14.Bd2.
14...Nd5 15.Na4
15.Ne4?? loses a piece after 15...f5.
15...Nb6 16.Bb3 Nxa4 17.Bxa4 f6 18.Re3 Bb7
Stockfish10's choice. Komodo10 gives 18...g5 19.Bxc6!? Rb8 (if 19...Kxc6, then 20.Rc3+, when the black king cannot escape checks from the white king's rook) 20.Rc3 Rxb2 21.f3!? Kb8 22.Bf2 with compensation for a pawn.
19.f4 g5?
Apparently missing one of the points behind 19.f4, but White also has good compensation for a pawn after 19...exf4 20.Rxe6 Rhe8 21.Rde1 Rxe6 22.Rxe6 Kd7 23.Bb3, according to the engines.
20.fxg5
Better it seems is the engines' 20.Be1! as after 20...a5 21.Red3 Bc8 White can give Black doubled isolanis with 22.fxe5 fxe5.
20...hxg5 21.Be1 a5 22.Red3 Bc8 23.Rc3
Cavendish's Daire McMahon later suggested 23.Rd6 Ra6 24.R1d3?
I believe I was worried about 24...Bf8, when 25.Bxa5+ (only move) Rxa5 26.Rxc6+ Kb8 27.Rd8 Bc5+ 28.Rxc5 Rxd8 29.Rxa5 Bb7 slightly favours Black, according to the engines, despite White being a pawn up. The point seems to be that White's pieces are a little uncoordinated.
However, the engines give 24...e4 25.Bxa5+ Rxa5 26.Rxc6+ Kb8 27.Rb3+ Ka8 with a winning advantage for Black. If 25.Rd1, then f5 with a large advantage for Black, eg 26.c3 Be5 27.R6d2 Bxh2+.
23...Bb7 24.Rc5 Kb6 25.Bf2 Kc7 26.Be1 Kb6
With hindsight, Black should give back the pawn with 26...Bf8 27.Rxa5, when Komodo10 reckons the position is equal but Stockfish10 slightly prefers Black.
![]() |
| White to play and win |
*****
*****
*****
*****
27.Rd7!!
This wins in all lines.
27...Bf8
If 27...Kxc5, then 28.Bf2+ Kb4 (or 28...Kc4 29.Bb3+ Kb5 30.a4+ Ka6 31.Bc4#) 29.Rxb7+ Kxa4 (if 29...Kc4, then 30.Bb3# ) 30.Bc5, and mate follows.
Or 27...Rhd8 28.Bf2! (28.Rxg7 Kxc5 29.Rxb7 is also strong) Ka6 (28...Rxd7? 29.Rxc6#), eg 29.Bxc6 Rxd7 30.Bxd7 Bf8 31.Rc7 Rd8 32.a4.
28.Rc3 Bc5+
If 28...Bb4, then 29.Bf2+ Ka6 30.Bxc6! Bxc3 31.Bxb7+ Kb5 32.Bxa8.
29.Rxc5! Kxc5 30.Bf2+ Kb4 31.Rxb7+ Kxa4
31...Kc4 32.Bb3#.
32.Bc5 1-0
Cavendish 2 won the match 8-2.
My updated Battersea statistics for 2019-20
Event*..Colour...Grade...Opponent's Grade...Result
CLL..…...B....…..168...………169...……….....W
CLL...…..B...…...168...………196...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………176...…………..L
LL....……W...…..168...…....…175...………….D
CLL...…..B...…...168...………192...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………181...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..168...………168...…………..L
EC...…….B...…..168...………175...……….….L
CLL...…...B.........170...………172...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..170...………183...…………..D
LL............W........170...…........180......……......L
LL....…….B...…..170....……...182...………….W
CLL...…...B...…..170...………183...……….….D
LL...……..B...…..170...………162...…………..W
LL...…….W...…..170...………172...…………..W
LL...…….W...…..170...………152...…………..L
CLL...…...B.........170..............194...................L
LL...…….W...…..170...….…...187...………….W
Overall this season for Battersea I have scored +5=5-8 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2018-19 I scored +12=12-13 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2017-18 I scored +10=8-9 for a grading performance of 175.
*CLL: Central London League; LL: London League; EC: Eastman Cup.
Monday, 24 February 2020
Doncaster Concluded
![]() |
| Black has just played 16....Bc5-b4? in Spanton (170) - George Ellames (153), Doncaster U171 Round 5 |
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
17.Ng4?
I only saw Nxb5+ - N(either)d5+ is also very strong - after moving. I never got another chance to win material, and the game ended in a draw 28 moves later.
My final score of +2=1-2 was a tournament grading performance of 151.8.
Friday, 21 February 2020
Compensation For The Exchnage
PLAYED on board four (of five), and was stand-in captain, in division one of the Central London League for Battersea 2 against title-chasing Rangers last night.
Carsten Pedersen (194) - Spanton (170)
Sicilian Closed
1.e4 c5 2.Nc3 g6 3.g3 Bg7 4.Bg2 Nc6 5.d3 d6 6.f4 e6 7.Nf3 Nge7 8.0-0 0-0 9.Be3 Nd4
The main move, although Bobby Fischer preferred 9...Rb8 when he had this position in 1956.
10.e5 Nef5 11.Bf2 Nxf3+ 12.Qxf3 Nd4 13.Qd1 dxe5 14.fxe5 Bxe5 15.Ne4 f5 16.Nxc5 Qd6
The game has been following the main line of the f4 Closed Sicilian, but here more common is 16...Qc7.
17.b4 Nb5?!
This would be good if grabbing the exchange were good, but since grabbing the exchange is bad, then better is 17...Nc6.
18.a4! Bxa1?
Better is 18...Nc7, but Stockfish10 and Komodo10 continue 19.d4 Bg7 20.c4 with a queenside initiative for White.
19.Qxa1 Nc7 20.Nxb7 Bxb7 21.Bxb7 Rab8 22.Bc5 Qd8
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
23.Bc6!
White has a pawn and the bishop-pair for the exchange, which is just about material parity. But Black is weak on the dark squares and his rooks have limited scope, so White is much better, as he would be after other retreats by the light-square bishop.
I expected 23.Bxf8, when 23...Qxf8 24.Bf3 Rxb4 is only slightly better for White.
23...Rf7?!
It was probably better to oblige White to win back the exchange by 23...Na6 24.Bxf8. However after 24...Qb6+ 25.Rf2 Rxf8 26.b5 White is much better.
24.b5 Nd5?!
Still reasonable is ...Na6, when 25.Ba3 (Black is back in the game after 25.bxa6? Qc7) Qb6+ 26.Kh1 Nc7 is, if nothing else, better than the game.
25.Qe5
Attacking e6 and threatening Bd4 to exploit the dark squares.
25...Qc8 26.Re1 a6 27.c4
Also good is 27.bxa6 as 27...Qxc6? runs into 28.Qxb8+.
27...Nf6 28.Bd6 Ng4 29.Qc5 Rbb7 30.Bxb7 Qxb7 31.Qc6 axb5 32.Qxb7 Rxb7 33.axb5
White has won back the exchange and emerged a good pawn up, and with unstoppable queenside passers.
The game finished:
33...Kf7 34.h3 Nf6 35.Rb1 Ne8 36.Be5 Nc7 37.Bxc7 Rxc7 38.b6 Rc8 39.c5 Ke7 40.c6 Kd6 41.c7 Re8 42.Rc1 1-0
Rangers won the match 4-1
My updated Battersea statistics for 2019-20
Event*..Colour...Grade...Opponent's Grade...Result
CLL..…...B....…..168...………169...……….....W
CLL...…..B...…...168...………196...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………176...…………..L
LL....……W...…..168...…....…175...………….D
CLL...…..B...…...168...………192...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………181...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..168...………168...…………..L
EC...…….B...…..168...………175...……….….L
CLL...…...B.........170...………172...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..170...………183...…………..D
LL............W........170...…........180......……......L
LL....…….B...…..170....……...182...………….W
CLL...…...B...…..170...………183...……….….D
LL...……..B...…..170...………162...…………..W
LL...…….W...…..170...………172...…………..W
LL...…….W...…..170...………152...…………..L
CLL...…...B.........170..............194...................L
Overall this season for Battersea I have scored +4=5-8 for a grading performance of 165.
In season 2018-19 I scored +12=12-13 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2017-18 I scored +10=8-9 for a grading performance of 175.
*CLL: Central London League; LL: London League; EC: Eastman Cup.
Carsten Pedersen (194) - Spanton (170)
Sicilian Closed
1.e4 c5 2.Nc3 g6 3.g3 Bg7 4.Bg2 Nc6 5.d3 d6 6.f4 e6 7.Nf3 Nge7 8.0-0 0-0 9.Be3 Nd4
The main move, although Bobby Fischer preferred 9...Rb8 when he had this position in 1956.
10.e5 Nef5 11.Bf2 Nxf3+ 12.Qxf3 Nd4 13.Qd1 dxe5 14.fxe5 Bxe5 15.Ne4 f5 16.Nxc5 Qd6
The game has been following the main line of the f4 Closed Sicilian, but here more common is 16...Qc7.
17.b4 Nb5?!
This would be good if grabbing the exchange were good, but since grabbing the exchange is bad, then better is 17...Nc6.
18.a4! Bxa1?
Better is 18...Nc7, but Stockfish10 and Komodo10 continue 19.d4 Bg7 20.c4 with a queenside initiative for White.
19.Qxa1 Nc7 20.Nxb7 Bxb7 21.Bxb7 Rab8 22.Bc5 Qd8
![]() |
| How should White proceed? |
*****
*****
*****
*****
23.Bc6!
White has a pawn and the bishop-pair for the exchange, which is just about material parity. But Black is weak on the dark squares and his rooks have limited scope, so White is much better, as he would be after other retreats by the light-square bishop.
I expected 23.Bxf8, when 23...Qxf8 24.Bf3 Rxb4 is only slightly better for White.
23...Rf7?!
It was probably better to oblige White to win back the exchange by 23...Na6 24.Bxf8. However after 24...Qb6+ 25.Rf2 Rxf8 26.b5 White is much better.
24.b5 Nd5?!
Still reasonable is ...Na6, when 25.Ba3 (Black is back in the game after 25.bxa6? Qc7) Qb6+ 26.Kh1 Nc7 is, if nothing else, better than the game.
25.Qe5
Attacking e6 and threatening Bd4 to exploit the dark squares.
25...Qc8 26.Re1 a6 27.c4
Also good is 27.bxa6 as 27...Qxc6? runs into 28.Qxb8+.
27...Nf6 28.Bd6 Ng4 29.Qc5 Rbb7 30.Bxb7 Qxb7 31.Qc6 axb5 32.Qxb7 Rxb7 33.axb5
White has won back the exchange and emerged a good pawn up, and with unstoppable queenside passers.
The game finished:
33...Kf7 34.h3 Nf6 35.Rb1 Ne8 36.Be5 Nc7 37.Bxc7 Rxc7 38.b6 Rc8 39.c5 Ke7 40.c6 Kd6 41.c7 Re8 42.Rc1 1-0
Rangers won the match 4-1
My updated Battersea statistics for 2019-20
Event*..Colour...Grade...Opponent's Grade...Result
CLL..…...B....…..168...………169...……….....W
CLL...…..B...…...168...………196...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………176...…………..L
LL....……W...…..168...…....…175...………….D
CLL...…..B...…...168...………192...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………181...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..168...………168...…………..L
EC...…….B...…..168...………175...……….….L
CLL...…...B.........170...………172...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..170...………183...…………..D
LL............W........170...…........180......……......L
LL....…….B...…..170....……...182...………….W
CLL...…...B...…..170...………183...……….….D
LL...……..B...…..170...………162...…………..W
LL...…….W...…..170...………172...…………..W
LL...…….W...…..170...………152...…………..L
CLL...…...B.........170..............194...................L
Overall this season for Battersea I have scored +4=5-8 for a grading performance of 165.
In season 2018-19 I scored +12=12-13 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2017-18 I scored +10=8-9 for a grading performance of 175.
*CLL: Central London League; LL: London League; EC: Eastman Cup.
Thursday, 20 February 2020
Morphing The French XIV
PLAYING on board eight (of 10) for Battersea last night against Athenaeum in the London League, I had my 14th chance to try to meet the French in the style of Paul Morphy.
Spanton (170) - John S Walton (152)
French Exchange
1.d4 e6 2.e4 d5 3.exd5 exd5 4.Nf3 Nf6 5.Bd3 Be7
Second in popularity to 5...Bd6.
6.0-0 0-0 7.Nc3
Five moves are more popular in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database, led by 7.h3, which restricts the black light-square bishop.
7...Re8
Another less-popular move, but there seems nothing wrong with it.
8.Re1 Bg4 9.h3 Bh5 10.Bg5 Bg6?
Missing a tactic.
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
11.Bxf6 gxf6
If 11...Bxf6, then 12.Rxe8+ Qxe8 13.Nxd5.
12.Nh4 Qd7 13.Qf3 Nc6 14.Nf5
14.Nxd5 is also good.
14...Nb4 15.Nxe7+
Stockfish10 and Komodo10 prefer 15.h4.
15...Rxe7 16.Rxe7 Qxe7 17.Bxg6
Here the engines prefer 17.a3 Nxd3 18.Nxd5 Qd6 19.cxd3 Kg7 20.Nf4.
17...hxg6 18.Nxd5 Nxd5 19.Qxd5 Qb4 20.Qb3!?
Returning the pawn in the hope of a small positional edge. The engines give 20.Rb1 Re8 21.c3 with a slight edge for White.
20...Qxd4 21.c3 Qb6 22.Rd1 Qxb3 23.axb3 Kf8
White is slightly better thanks to having his rook on an open file and having the possibility of creating a passed h pawn.
24.Kf1
The engines like 24.Rd7 Rc8 followed by gaining space with g4 or b4.
24...Ke7 25.Ke2 Rd8?
The pawn-ending is problematic for Black.
One line given by the engines runs 25...a5 26.h4 Ra6 with a position they reckon is equal.
26.Rxd8 Kxd8 27.Ke3 Ke7 28.h4 Kf8!?
This move looks silly at first glance, but it comes to be Komodo10's choice. The idea is that the white king will have great difficulty invading the queenside, so Black moves his king to the h file to combat White's potential passer.
29.g4 Kg7 30.Ke4 Kh6 31.b4 f5+!?
A good practical try.
32.gxf5 Kh5 33.c4 Kxh4 34.c5
Simpler is 34.fxg6, eg 34...fxg6 35.b5 Kg4 36.c5 g5 37.c6 bxc6 38.bxc6 a5 39.b3 Kh3 40.Kf5 g4 41.Kg5 g3 42.fxg3 Kxg3 43.Kf5 etc.
34...g5
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
35.Kf3??
This turns a win into a loss.
I rejected the winning 35.Ke5 (35.b5 is also good) because of 35...Kg4, missing that 36.Kf6 leads to a winning queen-and-pawn ending, eg 36...a6 37.Ke7 Kxf5 38.Kd7 c6 39.Kc7 Kg4 40.Kxb7 Kf3 41.Kxa6 g4 42.b5 Kxf2 43.bxc6 g3 44.c7 g2 45.c8Q g1Q 46.Qf5+ Ke3 47.c6 etc.
35...f6
White loses because he will eventually be in zugzwang.
36.b5 c6 37.bxc6 bxc6 38.Ke4 Kg4 39.f3+ Kg3 40.b4 a6 41.Ke3 g4 42.fxg4 Kxg4 43.Ke4 Kg5 0-1
Battersea won the match 7-3.
My updated Battersea statistics for 2019-20
Event*..Colour...Grade...Opponent's Grade...Result
CLL..…...B....…..168...………169...……….....W
CLL...…..B...…...168...………196...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………176...…………..L
LL....……W...…..168...…....…175...………….D
CLL...…..B...…...168...………192...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………181...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..168...………168...…………..L
EC...…….B...…..168...………175...……….….L
CLL...…...B.........170...………172...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..170...………183...…………..D
LL............W........170...…........180......……......L
LL....…….B...…..170....……...182...………….W
CLL...…...B...…..170...………183...……….….D
LL...……..B...…..170...………162...…………..W
LL...…….W...…..170...………172...…………..W
LL...…….W...…..170...………152...…………..L
Overall this season for Battersea I have scored +4=5-7 for a grading performance of 167.
In season 2018-19 I scored +12=12-13 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2017-18 I scored +10=8-9 for a grading performance of 175.
*CLL: Central London League; LL: London League; EC: Eastman Cup.
Spanton (170) - John S Walton (152)
French Exchange
1.d4 e6 2.e4 d5 3.exd5 exd5 4.Nf3 Nf6 5.Bd3 Be7
Second in popularity to 5...Bd6.
6.0-0 0-0 7.Nc3
Five moves are more popular in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database, led by 7.h3, which restricts the black light-square bishop.
7...Re8
Another less-popular move, but there seems nothing wrong with it.
8.Re1 Bg4 9.h3 Bh5 10.Bg5 Bg6?
Missing a tactic.
![]() |
| What did Black miss? |
*****
*****
*****
*****
11.Bxf6 gxf6
If 11...Bxf6, then 12.Rxe8+ Qxe8 13.Nxd5.
12.Nh4 Qd7 13.Qf3 Nc6 14.Nf5
14.Nxd5 is also good.
14...Nb4 15.Nxe7+
Stockfish10 and Komodo10 prefer 15.h4.
15...Rxe7 16.Rxe7 Qxe7 17.Bxg6
Here the engines prefer 17.a3 Nxd3 18.Nxd5 Qd6 19.cxd3 Kg7 20.Nf4.
17...hxg6 18.Nxd5 Nxd5 19.Qxd5 Qb4 20.Qb3!?
Returning the pawn in the hope of a small positional edge. The engines give 20.Rb1 Re8 21.c3 with a slight edge for White.
20...Qxd4 21.c3 Qb6 22.Rd1 Qxb3 23.axb3 Kf8
White is slightly better thanks to having his rook on an open file and having the possibility of creating a passed h pawn.
24.Kf1
The engines like 24.Rd7 Rc8 followed by gaining space with g4 or b4.
24...Ke7 25.Ke2 Rd8?
The pawn-ending is problematic for Black.
One line given by the engines runs 25...a5 26.h4 Ra6 with a position they reckon is equal.
26.Rxd8 Kxd8 27.Ke3 Ke7 28.h4 Kf8!?
This move looks silly at first glance, but it comes to be Komodo10's choice. The idea is that the white king will have great difficulty invading the queenside, so Black moves his king to the h file to combat White's potential passer.
29.g4 Kg7 30.Ke4 Kh6 31.b4 f5+!?
A good practical try.
32.gxf5 Kh5 33.c4 Kxh4 34.c5
Simpler is 34.fxg6, eg 34...fxg6 35.b5 Kg4 36.c5 g5 37.c6 bxc6 38.bxc6 a5 39.b3 Kh3 40.Kf5 g4 41.Kg5 g3 42.fxg3 Kxg3 43.Kf5 etc.
34...g5
![]() |
| How should White proceed? |
*****
*****
*****
*****
35.Kf3??
This turns a win into a loss.
I rejected the winning 35.Ke5 (35.b5 is also good) because of 35...Kg4, missing that 36.Kf6 leads to a winning queen-and-pawn ending, eg 36...a6 37.Ke7 Kxf5 38.Kd7 c6 39.Kc7 Kg4 40.Kxb7 Kf3 41.Kxa6 g4 42.b5 Kxf2 43.bxc6 g3 44.c7 g2 45.c8Q g1Q 46.Qf5+ Ke3 47.c6 etc.
35...f6
White loses because he will eventually be in zugzwang.
36.b5 c6 37.bxc6 bxc6 38.Ke4 Kg4 39.f3+ Kg3 40.b4 a6 41.Ke3 g4 42.fxg4 Kxg4 43.Ke4 Kg5 0-1
Battersea won the match 7-3.
My updated Battersea statistics for 2019-20
Event*..Colour...Grade...Opponent's Grade...Result
CLL..…...B....…..168...………169...……….....W
CLL...…..B...…...168...………196...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………176...…………..L
LL....……W...…..168...…....…175...………….D
CLL...…..B...…...168...………192...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………181...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..168...………168...…………..L
EC...…….B...…..168...………175...……….….L
CLL...…...B.........170...………172...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..170...………183...…………..D
LL............W........170...…........180......……......L
LL....…….B...…..170....……...182...………….W
CLL...…...B...…..170...………183...……….….D
LL...……..B...…..170...………162...…………..W
LL...…….W...…..170...………172...…………..W
LL...…….W...…..170...………152...…………..L
Overall this season for Battersea I have scored +4=5-7 for a grading performance of 167.
In season 2018-19 I scored +12=12-13 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2017-18 I scored +10=8-9 for a grading performance of 175.
*CLL: Central London League; LL: London League; EC: Eastman Cup.
Friday, 14 February 2020
Morphing The French XIII
PLAYED in division one of the Central London League on board five (of five) for Battersea 2 against Pimlico Bishops last night.
The game gave me my 13th chance to try to play against the French in the style of Paul Morphy.
Spanton (170) - Robert Stern (172)
French Exchange
1.d4 e6 2.e4 d5 3.exd5 exd5 4.Nf3 Nf6 5.Bd3 c5 6.0-0
Stockfish10 and Komodo10 like 6.c3, but I did not believe that is the type of move Morphy would play if getting on with development were possible.
6.dxc5!? Bxc5 produces a very different type of game.
6...c4 7.Re1+ Be7 8.Bf1 0-0 9.b3
Kasparov played 9.Bg5 in a win over Korchnoi at Tilburg (Netherlands) 1991.
9...cxb3 10.axb3 Nc6 11.Nbd2
The main move is 11.Ne5 but the text has also been tried by a few 2400+ players.
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
11...h6
I did not understand the point of this, but RS explained after the game that his idea is to give his light-square bishop a retreat square on h7 in the event of it going to f5 and being attacked by Nh4.
However the immediate 11...Bf5 features in three games in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database by players rated 2431-2575. The point is that 12.Nh4?! runs into 12...Bg4, when the d4 pawn is hanging.
If 13.f3?, Black has 13...Be6, when both d4 and the knight at h4 are in danger.
If 13.Nhf3 (13.Ndf3?? loses to 13...Ne4, when the vulnerability of the knight at h4 is again apparent) then simply 13...Nxd4 is good.
That leaves 13.Be2 Bxe2 14.Qxe2 Re8 (14...Nxd4?! 15.Qxe7 Nxc2 gives an unclear position, but not 15...Re8?? 16.Qxd8), and now the engines agree the best White has is 15.Qd1 Nxd4 16.Bb2 Qb6 17.Bxd4 Qxd4 18.Rxe7 Rxe7 19.Nf5 Qe5 20.Nxe7+ Qxe7, when Black emerges a pawn up.
12.Bb2 Bf5
The arguably somewhat inconsistent 12...Bg4 was played in Lars Oskar Hauge (2431) - Gupta Prithu (2219), Rilton Cup (Stockholm) 2016. That game continued 13.h3 Bh5 14.Bd3 Bd6 15.c4 with a roughly level position (but 1-0, 30 moves).
13.Ne5 Re8
13...Nb4 14.Rc1 Na2 16.Ra1 Nb4 15.Ra1 Nb4 would be an invitation to an early draw. However 14...Rc8 would keep the game going.
14.Nxc6!?
This unisolates the d5 pawn but isolates the a pawn and creates a new weakness at c6. It also means White's backward c pawn is no longer on a half-open file.
14...bxc6 15.Nf3 Ne4
The engines give 15...a5!?, preventing a White piece going to a6.
16.Ne5 Qc7
Possible is 16...Bd6!? as 17.Nxc6? (the position is difficult to assess - one line given by the engines runs 17.Ra6 Bc8!? 18.Rxc6!? Bb7 19.Rxd6 Nxd6, when White has a pawn and the bishop-pair for the exchange) Bxh2+! 18.Kxh2 Qh4+ 19.Kg1 Qxf2+ gives what the engines reckon is a winning attack for Black.
17.Ra6 c5?
The engines give 17...Qb7, when they reckon 18.Nxc6 Bg5 19.Ne5 Nd2 20.Ra5 Nxf1 provides good compensation for the pawn.
18.Qf3 Be6
Best, according to the engines, is 18...Bh4 19.g3 cxd4 20.Bxd4 Bf6 21.Rxf6 gxf6 22.Nxf7 Qxf7 23.Qxf5, when, for the exchange, White has a pawn, the bishop-pair and an attack.
19.Rxe6! Ng5
19...fxe6 20.Qf7+ Kh8 21.dxc5 wins for White, as does 20...Kh7 21.Qg6+ Kg8 22.Qxe6+ Kh8 23.Rxe4! (other moves are also good) dxe4 24.Ng6+ Kh7 25.Qf5 etc.
20.Qh5 fxe6 21.h4 Ne4
Not 21...Nh7?? 22.Qf7+ Kh8 23.Ng6#.
22.Qf7+ Kh7
If 22...Kh8 then 23.dxc5 quickly wins.
23.f3
Even stronger is giving up a second exchange by 23.Rxe4! dxe4, and then 24.Qg6+, but I was not confident enough about this.
23...cxd4
I expected the engines' choice 23...Bd6, when I intended keeping the attack going by 24.Qg6+ Kg8 25.fxe4. The engines continue 25...Bxe5 26.dxe5 d4 27.Bc4, when White has two bishops for a rook, and an ongoing attack.
24.Qg6+ Kg8 25.Qxe6+ Kh8 26.Nf7+ Kh7 27.Qf5+??
I was so used to calculating lines with black pawns on g7 and h6 that I forgot they could move!
Both 27.Qxd5 Nc5 28.Bxd4 Bxh4 29.Rxe8 Rxe8 30.Nd6 and 27.Rxe4 dxe4 28.Qxe4+ g6 29.Bd3 Rg8 30.h5 win for White.
27...g6 28.Qxd5 Nf6
This looks strong but Black had to find 28...Nc3! 29.Rxe7 (White has a pawn for the exchange, but no bishop-pair, after 29.Bxc3?! dxc3, and his pieces are uncoordinated) 29...Qxe7 30.Qxd4 Qe3+ 31.Qxe3 Rxe3, when he emerges with two rooks for two bishops and two pawns, and is much better, according to the engines.
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
29.Ng5+!
Not 29.Qxd4?? Bc5.
29...hxg5
29...Kh8 30.Qf7 hxg5 - there is nothing better - transposes.
30.Qf7+ Kh8 31.Bxd4 Qd6 32.c3 Rf8 33.Qxg6 Rae8 34.Qh6+
34.Bd3 also quickly mates.
34...Kg8 35.Bc4+ Rf7
If 35...Nd5 then 36.Qg7#.
36.Qg6+ Kh8 37.Bxf7 Qg3 38.Qh6#
The match was drawn 2.5-2.5.
My updated Battersea statistics for 2019-20
Event*..Colour...Grade...Opponent's Grade...Result
CLL..…...B....…..168...………169...……….....W
CLL...…..B...…...168...………196...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………176...…………..L
LL....……W...…..168...…....…175...………….D
CLL...…..B...…...168...………192...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………181...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..168...………168...…………..L
EC...…….B...…..168...………175...……….….L
CLL...…...B.........170...………172...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..170...………183...…………..D
LL............W........170...…........180......……......L
LL....…….B...…..170....……...182...………….W
CLL...…...B...…..170...………183...……….….D
LL...……..B...…..170...………162...…………..W
LL...…….W...…..170...………172...…………..W
Overall this season for Battersea I have scored +4=5-6 for a grading performance of 171.
In season 2018-19 I scored +12=12-13 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2017-18 I scored +10=8-9 for a grading performance of 175.
*CLL: Central London League; LL: London League; EC: Eastman Cup.
The game gave me my 13th chance to try to play against the French in the style of Paul Morphy.
Spanton (170) - Robert Stern (172)
French Exchange
1.d4 e6 2.e4 d5 3.exd5 exd5 4.Nf3 Nf6 5.Bd3 c5 6.0-0
Stockfish10 and Komodo10 like 6.c3, but I did not believe that is the type of move Morphy would play if getting on with development were possible.
6.dxc5!? Bxc5 produces a very different type of game.
6...c4 7.Re1+ Be7 8.Bf1 0-0 9.b3
Kasparov played 9.Bg5 in a win over Korchnoi at Tilburg (Netherlands) 1991.
9...cxb3 10.axb3 Nc6 11.Nbd2
The main move is 11.Ne5 but the text has also been tried by a few 2400+ players.
![]() |
| How should Black proceed? |
*****
*****
*****
*****
11...h6
I did not understand the point of this, but RS explained after the game that his idea is to give his light-square bishop a retreat square on h7 in the event of it going to f5 and being attacked by Nh4.
However the immediate 11...Bf5 features in three games in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database by players rated 2431-2575. The point is that 12.Nh4?! runs into 12...Bg4, when the d4 pawn is hanging.
If 13.f3?, Black has 13...Be6, when both d4 and the knight at h4 are in danger.
If 13.Nhf3 (13.Ndf3?? loses to 13...Ne4, when the vulnerability of the knight at h4 is again apparent) then simply 13...Nxd4 is good.
That leaves 13.Be2 Bxe2 14.Qxe2 Re8 (14...Nxd4?! 15.Qxe7 Nxc2 gives an unclear position, but not 15...Re8?? 16.Qxd8), and now the engines agree the best White has is 15.Qd1 Nxd4 16.Bb2 Qb6 17.Bxd4 Qxd4 18.Rxe7 Rxe7 19.Nf5 Qe5 20.Nxe7+ Qxe7, when Black emerges a pawn up.
12.Bb2 Bf5
The arguably somewhat inconsistent 12...Bg4 was played in Lars Oskar Hauge (2431) - Gupta Prithu (2219), Rilton Cup (Stockholm) 2016. That game continued 13.h3 Bh5 14.Bd3 Bd6 15.c4 with a roughly level position (but 1-0, 30 moves).
13.Ne5 Re8
13...Nb4 14.Rc1 Na2 16.Ra1 Nb4 15.Ra1 Nb4 would be an invitation to an early draw. However 14...Rc8 would keep the game going.
14.Nxc6!?
This unisolates the d5 pawn but isolates the a pawn and creates a new weakness at c6. It also means White's backward c pawn is no longer on a half-open file.
14...bxc6 15.Nf3 Ne4
The engines give 15...a5!?, preventing a White piece going to a6.
16.Ne5 Qc7
Possible is 16...Bd6!? as 17.Nxc6? (the position is difficult to assess - one line given by the engines runs 17.Ra6 Bc8!? 18.Rxc6!? Bb7 19.Rxd6 Nxd6, when White has a pawn and the bishop-pair for the exchange) Bxh2+! 18.Kxh2 Qh4+ 19.Kg1 Qxf2+ gives what the engines reckon is a winning attack for Black.
17.Ra6 c5?
The engines give 17...Qb7, when they reckon 18.Nxc6 Bg5 19.Ne5 Nd2 20.Ra5 Nxf1 provides good compensation for the pawn.
18.Qf3 Be6
Best, according to the engines, is 18...Bh4 19.g3 cxd4 20.Bxd4 Bf6 21.Rxf6 gxf6 22.Nxf7 Qxf7 23.Qxf5, when, for the exchange, White has a pawn, the bishop-pair and an attack.
19.Rxe6! Ng5
19...fxe6 20.Qf7+ Kh8 21.dxc5 wins for White, as does 20...Kh7 21.Qg6+ Kg8 22.Qxe6+ Kh8 23.Rxe4! (other moves are also good) dxe4 24.Ng6+ Kh7 25.Qf5 etc.
20.Qh5 fxe6 21.h4 Ne4
Not 21...Nh7?? 22.Qf7+ Kh8 23.Ng6#.
22.Qf7+ Kh7
If 22...Kh8 then 23.dxc5 quickly wins.
23.f3
Even stronger is giving up a second exchange by 23.Rxe4! dxe4, and then 24.Qg6+, but I was not confident enough about this.
23...cxd4
I expected the engines' choice 23...Bd6, when I intended keeping the attack going by 24.Qg6+ Kg8 25.fxe4. The engines continue 25...Bxe5 26.dxe5 d4 27.Bc4, when White has two bishops for a rook, and an ongoing attack.
24.Qg6+ Kg8 25.Qxe6+ Kh8 26.Nf7+ Kh7 27.Qf5+??
I was so used to calculating lines with black pawns on g7 and h6 that I forgot they could move!
Both 27.Qxd5 Nc5 28.Bxd4 Bxh4 29.Rxe8 Rxe8 30.Nd6 and 27.Rxe4 dxe4 28.Qxe4+ g6 29.Bd3 Rg8 30.h5 win for White.
27...g6 28.Qxd5 Nf6
This looks strong but Black had to find 28...Nc3! 29.Rxe7 (White has a pawn for the exchange, but no bishop-pair, after 29.Bxc3?! dxc3, and his pieces are uncoordinated) 29...Qxe7 30.Qxd4 Qe3+ 31.Qxe3 Rxe3, when he emerges with two rooks for two bishops and two pawns, and is much better, according to the engines.
![]() |
| White to play and win |
*****
*****
*****
*****
29.Ng5+!
Not 29.Qxd4?? Bc5.
29...hxg5
29...Kh8 30.Qf7 hxg5 - there is nothing better - transposes.
30.Qf7+ Kh8 31.Bxd4 Qd6 32.c3 Rf8 33.Qxg6 Rae8 34.Qh6+
34.Bd3 also quickly mates.
34...Kg8 35.Bc4+ Rf7
If 35...Nd5 then 36.Qg7#.
36.Qg6+ Kh8 37.Bxf7 Qg3 38.Qh6#
The match was drawn 2.5-2.5.
My updated Battersea statistics for 2019-20
Event*..Colour...Grade...Opponent's Grade...Result
CLL..…...B....…..168...………169...……….....W
CLL...…..B...…...168...………196...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………176...…………..L
LL....……W...…..168...…....…175...………….D
CLL...…..B...…...168...………192...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………181...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..168...………168...…………..L
EC...…….B...…..168...………175...……….….L
CLL...…...B.........170...………172...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..170...………183...…………..D
LL............W........170...…........180......……......L
LL....…….B...…..170....……...182...………….W
CLL...…...B...…..170...………183...……….….D
LL...……..B...…..170...………162...…………..W
LL...…….W...…..170...………172...…………..W
Overall this season for Battersea I have scored +4=5-6 for a grading performance of 171.
In season 2018-19 I scored +12=12-13 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2017-18 I scored +10=8-9 for a grading performance of 175.
*CLL: Central London League; LL: London League; EC: Eastman Cup.
Thursday, 13 February 2020
Unusual Closed Sicilian
PLAYED on board five (of 10) in the London League's second division for Battersea 2 against Hackney 2 last night.
Paul Conway (162) - Spanton (170)
Sicilian Closed
1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 g6 3.d3!?
White is playing a Closed Sicilian but without the move Nc3. The idea is that in many lines of the Closed, Black drops a knight into d4. If White captures it, the reply ...cxd4 is usually good for Black. So instead White at some point withdraws his queen's knight to d1 or e2, plays c3 to evict the black knight and later redevelops the queen's knight (if Black has not exchanged it). All this takes time, so players started experimenting with 2.g3 (rather than 2.Nc3). But many found 2...d5 an annoying answer. Hence the idea of first playing 2.Nf3, as if going for an Open or Bb5(+) Sicilian. The drawback is that the white king's knight blocks the white f pawn, which often advances to f4 in the Closed.
3...Bg7 4.g3 Nc6
Still possible, but not popular, is ...d5!?
5.Bg2 d6 6.0-0
This position could also arise from a King's Indian Attack in which Black has not played ...d5, and so White has not been obliged to play Nbd2. Ironically, some KIA players regard this as a superior version of their opening because the queen's knight still has the option of developing at c3.
6...e5
Carlsen and Kasparov have gone for this Botvinnik/Nimzowitsch pawn-formation. Other popular moves are 6...Nf6 and 6...e6.
7.c3
This is the most-popular move, but Carlsen has played 7.Nc3.
7...Nge7
Black now definitely has a Botvinnik set-up. The other main development of the king's knight, 7...Nf6, is how Nimzowitsch often played in this type of position. I was tempted to play it to put pressure on the e4 pawn, which White will need to protect if he wants to blast open the black centre with d4. But the e4 pawn is easily protected by Re1, and a knight on f6 blocks the action of the black fianchettoed bishop.
8.Re1
This position is often reached with White to move as it can arise from a KIA against the French in which Black plays 1...e6 before later pushing the e pawn a second time.
8...0-0 9.Nbd2 d5!?
Going for a Maroczy Bind. In playing this I was fairly sure my main analysis engines. Stockfish10 and Komodo10, would not approve, and I was right. They much prefer the mainline move, 9...h6, which they reckon is at least equal for Black.
10.Qc2
I was expecting 10.exd5 Nxd5 11.Nc4, when Black has to decide between 11...f6, which is a normal type of move in a Maroczy Bind, but here does the black fianchettoed bishop no favours, and 11...Re8. In both cases the engines prefer White.
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
10...d4!?
This appears to be new in this exact position, although the game transposes to known lines. Gaining space like this invites the lever f4, but that is more effective when White has a rook on f1. Here I felt White is not well-placed to take advantage of Black's multiple pawn moves (six already), so the gain of space is justified. The engines agree (with the move, at least, I cannot vouch for the explanation).
11.a4 h6
Preparing ...Be6 by keeping a white knight out of g5, and also denying the white dark-square bishop a development square on the kingside. However, the engines prefer the immediate 11...Be6!?, and if 12.Ng5, then 12...Bc8 with ...h6 to come.
11...a5 was played in Raymond Kearsley (1648) - Alex van Galen (1400), Guernsey Holiday 2002, which continued 12.Nc4 Be6 13.Na3?! f5? 14.Ng5 with a strong game for White (1-0, 33 moves).
12.Rb1?!
A handy rule-of-thumb from Cecil Purdy, the first world correspondence champion, is that you should never place a rook behind an unmoved pawn, even if you intend to move the pawn fairly quickly (doubtless he meant to exclude from this advice the move 0-0, which usually places the king's rook behind a pawn on f2). Even without the rule, the text is doubtful as White is unlikely to be in position to move the b pawn anytime soon.
12...Be6 13.Nb3
Not 13.b4? dxc3 14.Qxc3 cxb4.
More normal is 13.Nc4 but the knight can be evicted by ...a6 and ...b5.
13...b6 14.Rd1 Qd7 15.c4?
Closing the centre when you have less space is rarely a good idea when you have no easily arranged pawn-breaks. Here the move is also bad on tactical grounds.
15...Nb4 16.Qe2 Qxa4 17.Nfd2
Not 17.Nbd2? Nxd3.
17...Qd7 18.Ra1 a5 19.Nb1?
White's pieces are short of squares on the queenside, and this does not help. The engines suggest 19.Nf3 a4 20.Nbd2 Nec6, when one line continues 21.Ne1 Na5 22.Ra3 b5 with a large advantage for Black.
19...a4 20.N3d2 Nc2 21.Ra2 Nc6
White cannot avoid losing an exchange.
22.Na3 N6b4 23.Nxc2 Nxa2 24.Na3 Qe8 25.Nb5 Ra5
Not 25...Bd7? 26.Nc7.
26.Nc7 Qd7 27.Nxe6 Qxe6 28.Nb1 b5 29.Na3 b4 30.Bd2
The engines do not like the 'obvious' 30.Nb5, conitnuing 30...a3 eg 31.bxa3 Nc3 32.Nxc3 dxc3 33.axb4 cxb4, when Black has the exchange and two very striong connected passed pawns.
30...Ra6 31.Nb1 Rb8 32.h4 a3 33.bxa3 bxa3 34.Qe1 Rb2 35.Kh2 h5 36.Bh3 Qb6 37.Bd7
White has managed to get his king's bishop into a position where it can possibly help on the queenside, but the black passed pawn is too strong.
37...Nb4
Threatening ...a2.
38.Bxb4 cxb4 39.Nd2 Bh6 40.Nf3 Ra5 41.Ng5 Qf6 42.Nh3 Qb6 43.Ra1
If White repeated with 43.Ng5, I intended 43...Bxg5 44.hxg5 Qd8, winning a second pawn to go with the exchange.
43...b3 44.Kg2 Rc2 45.Ng5 Bxg5 46.hxg5 b2 0-1
The match is tied 4.5-4.5 with one game, in which the Battersea 2 player has a promising position, adjourned.
My updated Battersea statistics for 2019-20
Event*..Colour...Grade...Opponent's Grade...Result
CLL..…...B....…..168...………169...……….....W
CLL...…..B...…...168...………196...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………176...…………..L
LL....……W...…..168...…....…175...………….D
CLL...…..B...…...168...………192...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………181...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..168...………168...…………..L
EC...…….B...…..168...………175...……….….L
CLL...…...B.........170...………172...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..170...………183...…………..D
LL............W........170...…........180......……......L
LL....…….B...…..170....……...182...………….W
CLL...…...B...…..170...………183...……….….D
LL...……..B...…..170...………162...…………..W
Overall this season for Battersea I have scored +3=5-6 for a grading performance of 167.
In season 2018-19 I scored +12=12-13 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2017-18 I scored +10=8-9 for a grading performance of 175.
*CLL: Central London League; LL: London League; EC: Eastman Cup.
Paul Conway (162) - Spanton (170)
Sicilian Closed
1.e4 c5 2.Nf3 g6 3.d3!?
White is playing a Closed Sicilian but without the move Nc3. The idea is that in many lines of the Closed, Black drops a knight into d4. If White captures it, the reply ...cxd4 is usually good for Black. So instead White at some point withdraws his queen's knight to d1 or e2, plays c3 to evict the black knight and later redevelops the queen's knight (if Black has not exchanged it). All this takes time, so players started experimenting with 2.g3 (rather than 2.Nc3). But many found 2...d5 an annoying answer. Hence the idea of first playing 2.Nf3, as if going for an Open or Bb5(+) Sicilian. The drawback is that the white king's knight blocks the white f pawn, which often advances to f4 in the Closed.
3...Bg7 4.g3 Nc6
Still possible, but not popular, is ...d5!?
5.Bg2 d6 6.0-0
This position could also arise from a King's Indian Attack in which Black has not played ...d5, and so White has not been obliged to play Nbd2. Ironically, some KIA players regard this as a superior version of their opening because the queen's knight still has the option of developing at c3.
6...e5
Carlsen and Kasparov have gone for this Botvinnik/Nimzowitsch pawn-formation. Other popular moves are 6...Nf6 and 6...e6.
7.c3
This is the most-popular move, but Carlsen has played 7.Nc3.
7...Nge7
Black now definitely has a Botvinnik set-up. The other main development of the king's knight, 7...Nf6, is how Nimzowitsch often played in this type of position. I was tempted to play it to put pressure on the e4 pawn, which White will need to protect if he wants to blast open the black centre with d4. But the e4 pawn is easily protected by Re1, and a knight on f6 blocks the action of the black fianchettoed bishop.
8.Re1
This position is often reached with White to move as it can arise from a KIA against the French in which Black plays 1...e6 before later pushing the e pawn a second time.
8...0-0 9.Nbd2 d5!?
Going for a Maroczy Bind. In playing this I was fairly sure my main analysis engines. Stockfish10 and Komodo10, would not approve, and I was right. They much prefer the mainline move, 9...h6, which they reckon is at least equal for Black.
10.Qc2
I was expecting 10.exd5 Nxd5 11.Nc4, when Black has to decide between 11...f6, which is a normal type of move in a Maroczy Bind, but here does the black fianchettoed bishop no favours, and 11...Re8. In both cases the engines prefer White.
![]() |
| How should Black proceed? |
*****
*****
*****
*****
10...d4!?
This appears to be new in this exact position, although the game transposes to known lines. Gaining space like this invites the lever f4, but that is more effective when White has a rook on f1. Here I felt White is not well-placed to take advantage of Black's multiple pawn moves (six already), so the gain of space is justified. The engines agree (with the move, at least, I cannot vouch for the explanation).
11.a4 h6
Preparing ...Be6 by keeping a white knight out of g5, and also denying the white dark-square bishop a development square on the kingside. However, the engines prefer the immediate 11...Be6!?, and if 12.Ng5, then 12...Bc8 with ...h6 to come.
11...a5 was played in Raymond Kearsley (1648) - Alex van Galen (1400), Guernsey Holiday 2002, which continued 12.Nc4 Be6 13.Na3?! f5? 14.Ng5 with a strong game for White (1-0, 33 moves).
12.Rb1?!
A handy rule-of-thumb from Cecil Purdy, the first world correspondence champion, is that you should never place a rook behind an unmoved pawn, even if you intend to move the pawn fairly quickly (doubtless he meant to exclude from this advice the move 0-0, which usually places the king's rook behind a pawn on f2). Even without the rule, the text is doubtful as White is unlikely to be in position to move the b pawn anytime soon.
12...Be6 13.Nb3
Not 13.b4? dxc3 14.Qxc3 cxb4.
More normal is 13.Nc4 but the knight can be evicted by ...a6 and ...b5.
13...b6 14.Rd1 Qd7 15.c4?
Closing the centre when you have less space is rarely a good idea when you have no easily arranged pawn-breaks. Here the move is also bad on tactical grounds.
15...Nb4 16.Qe2 Qxa4 17.Nfd2
Not 17.Nbd2? Nxd3.
17...Qd7 18.Ra1 a5 19.Nb1?
White's pieces are short of squares on the queenside, and this does not help. The engines suggest 19.Nf3 a4 20.Nbd2 Nec6, when one line continues 21.Ne1 Na5 22.Ra3 b5 with a large advantage for Black.
19...a4 20.N3d2 Nc2 21.Ra2 Nc6
White cannot avoid losing an exchange.
22.Na3 N6b4 23.Nxc2 Nxa2 24.Na3 Qe8 25.Nb5 Ra5
Not 25...Bd7? 26.Nc7.
26.Nc7 Qd7 27.Nxe6 Qxe6 28.Nb1 b5 29.Na3 b4 30.Bd2
The engines do not like the 'obvious' 30.Nb5, conitnuing 30...a3 eg 31.bxa3 Nc3 32.Nxc3 dxc3 33.axb4 cxb4, when Black has the exchange and two very striong connected passed pawns.
30...Ra6 31.Nb1 Rb8 32.h4 a3 33.bxa3 bxa3 34.Qe1 Rb2 35.Kh2 h5 36.Bh3 Qb6 37.Bd7
White has managed to get his king's bishop into a position where it can possibly help on the queenside, but the black passed pawn is too strong.
37...Nb4
Threatening ...a2.
38.Bxb4 cxb4 39.Nd2 Bh6 40.Nf3 Ra5 41.Ng5 Qf6 42.Nh3 Qb6 43.Ra1
If White repeated with 43.Ng5, I intended 43...Bxg5 44.hxg5 Qd8, winning a second pawn to go with the exchange.
43...b3 44.Kg2 Rc2 45.Ng5 Bxg5 46.hxg5 b2 0-1
The match is tied 4.5-4.5 with one game, in which the Battersea 2 player has a promising position, adjourned.
My updated Battersea statistics for 2019-20
Event*..Colour...Grade...Opponent's Grade...Result
CLL..…...B....…..168...………169...……….....W
CLL...…..B...…...168...………196...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………176...…………..L
LL....……W...…..168...…....…175...………….D
CLL...…..B...…...168...………192...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………181...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..168...………168...…………..L
EC...…….B...…..168...………175...……….….L
CLL...…...B.........170...………172...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..170...………183...…………..D
LL............W........170...…........180......……......L
LL....…….B...…..170....……...182...………….W
CLL...…...B...…..170...………183...……….….D
LL...……..B...…..170...………162...…………..W
Overall this season for Battersea I have scored +3=5-6 for a grading performance of 167.
In season 2018-19 I scored +12=12-13 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2017-18 I scored +10=8-9 for a grading performance of 175.
*CLL: Central London League; LL: London League; EC: Eastman Cup.
Friday, 31 January 2020
Sharp Albin
PLAYED top board last night in division two of the Central London League for Battersea 3 against HMC 2.
John M Bennett (183) - Spanton (170)
Albin Countergambit
1.d4 d5 2.c4 e5 3.dxe5 d4 4.Nf3 Nc6 5.g3
This is still the most popular move in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database, but is being increasingly challenged by 5.a3 (Emanuel Lasker's original choice back in 1893) and, to a lesser extent, by 5.Nbd2.
5...Nge7 6.Bg2 Ng6 7.Bg5!?
The main move is 7.0-0 but the text obliges Black to make an awkward-looking reply.
7...Qd7
The 'obvious' 7...Be7? is simply met by 8.Bxe7, when 8...Qxe7 9.Nxd4 drops the important d pawn. If Black then tries 9...Qb4+, White has 10.Nc3 with what Stockfish10 and Komodo10 reckon is a winning position.
8.0-0 h6!?
8...Ngxe5 9.Nxe5 Nxe5 10.Qc2?! (10.Qb3 is probably better) Qf5 worked out well in Jonathan Wells (2072) - Spanton (2020), Paignton (0-1, 54 moves), but the text is maybe even stronger.
JB revealed afterwards he had the position after 8...h6!? more than 20 years ago in Dubai. Back then he played 9.Bd2 but concluded that stronger is 9.Bc1. Nevertheless, for some reason he could not explain, this time he played ...
9.Bd2
9.Bf4 Nxf4 10.gxf4 g5!? 11.e3?! (11.Nbd2, as played by Boris Gelfand in a 2004 blindfold rapid loss to Alexander Morozevich, seems better) dxe3 12.Qxd7+ Bxd7 13.fxe3 Bc5 was good for Black in Roman Bradac (2031) - Spanton (1961), Highlands Open (Czech Rep) 2014 (0-1, 23 moves).
Not as bad as it looks is 9.Bh4?! Ngxe5 10.Nxe5 Nxe5, eg 11.Nd2 g5?! 12.f4. But 11...f6 really does threaten ...g5, and the engines reckon White has to play 12.g4 Qxg4 13.Bg3, although they have Black only slightly better.
9...Ngxe5 10.Nxe5 Nxe5 11.Qb3 Bc5 12.Bxb7!?
This looks impossible at first glance because of 12...Rb8, but then 13.Bxc8 Qxc8 14.Qa4+ was a little better for White in Trevor Coote (2104) - Spanton (1880), Hastings 2017-18 (1-0, 34 moves).
12...Bxb7 13.Qxb7 0-0 14.b4 Rab8 15.Qe4
15.Qa6? d3 gives Black a very strong attack.
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
15...Nxc4! 16.bxc5 Rxb1 17.Raxb1 Nxd2 18.Qd3 ½–½
On 18.Qb7, I planned 18...Re8.
My updated Battersea statistics for 2019-20
Event*..Colour...Grade...Opponent's Grade...Result
CLL..…...B....…..168...………169...……….....W
CLL...…..B...…...168...………196...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………176...…………..L
LL....……W...…..168...…....…175...………….D
CLL...…..B...…...168...………192...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………181...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..168...………168...…………..L
EC...…….B...…..168...………175...……….….L
CLL...…...B.........170...………172...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..170...………183...…………..D
LL............W........170...…........180......……......L
LL....…….B...…..170....……...182...………….W
CLL...…...B...…..170...………183...……….….D
Overall this season for Battersea I have scored +2=5-6 for a grading performance of 164.
In season 2018-19 I scored +12=12-13 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2017-18 I scored +10=8-9 for a grading performance of 175.
*CLL: Central London League; LL: London League; EC: Eastman Cup.
John M Bennett (183) - Spanton (170)
Albin Countergambit
1.d4 d5 2.c4 e5 3.dxe5 d4 4.Nf3 Nc6 5.g3
This is still the most popular move in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database, but is being increasingly challenged by 5.a3 (Emanuel Lasker's original choice back in 1893) and, to a lesser extent, by 5.Nbd2.
5...Nge7 6.Bg2 Ng6 7.Bg5!?
The main move is 7.0-0 but the text obliges Black to make an awkward-looking reply.
7...Qd7
The 'obvious' 7...Be7? is simply met by 8.Bxe7, when 8...Qxe7 9.Nxd4 drops the important d pawn. If Black then tries 9...Qb4+, White has 10.Nc3 with what Stockfish10 and Komodo10 reckon is a winning position.
8.0-0 h6!?
8...Ngxe5 9.Nxe5 Nxe5 10.Qc2?! (10.Qb3 is probably better) Qf5 worked out well in Jonathan Wells (2072) - Spanton (2020), Paignton (0-1, 54 moves), but the text is maybe even stronger.
JB revealed afterwards he had the position after 8...h6!? more than 20 years ago in Dubai. Back then he played 9.Bd2 but concluded that stronger is 9.Bc1. Nevertheless, for some reason he could not explain, this time he played ...
9.Bd2
9.Bf4 Nxf4 10.gxf4 g5!? 11.e3?! (11.Nbd2, as played by Boris Gelfand in a 2004 blindfold rapid loss to Alexander Morozevich, seems better) dxe3 12.Qxd7+ Bxd7 13.fxe3 Bc5 was good for Black in Roman Bradac (2031) - Spanton (1961), Highlands Open (Czech Rep) 2014 (0-1, 23 moves).
Not as bad as it looks is 9.Bh4?! Ngxe5 10.Nxe5 Nxe5, eg 11.Nd2 g5?! 12.f4. But 11...f6 really does threaten ...g5, and the engines reckon White has to play 12.g4 Qxg4 13.Bg3, although they have Black only slightly better.
9...Ngxe5 10.Nxe5 Nxe5 11.Qb3 Bc5 12.Bxb7!?
This looks impossible at first glance because of 12...Rb8, but then 13.Bxc8 Qxc8 14.Qa4+ was a little better for White in Trevor Coote (2104) - Spanton (1880), Hastings 2017-18 (1-0, 34 moves).
12...Bxb7 13.Qxb7 0-0 14.b4 Rab8 15.Qe4
15.Qa6? d3 gives Black a very strong attack.
![]() |
| Black to play and draw |
*****
*****
*****
*****
15...Nxc4! 16.bxc5 Rxb1 17.Raxb1 Nxd2 18.Qd3 ½–½
On 18.Qb7, I planned 18...Re8.
My updated Battersea statistics for 2019-20
Event*..Colour...Grade...Opponent's Grade...Result
CLL..…...B....…..168...………169...……….....W
CLL...…..B...…...168...………196...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………176...…………..L
LL....……W...…..168...…....…175...………….D
CLL...…..B...…...168...………192...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………181...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..168...………168...…………..L
EC...…….B...…..168...………175...……….….L
CLL...…...B.........170...………172...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..170...………183...…………..D
LL............W........170...…........180......……......L
LL....…….B...…..170....……...182...………….W
CLL...…...B...…..170...………183...……….….D
Overall this season for Battersea I have scored +2=5-6 for a grading performance of 164.
In season 2018-19 I scored +12=12-13 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2017-18 I scored +10=8-9 for a grading performance of 175.
*CLL: Central London League; LL: London League; EC: Eastman Cup.
Thursday, 30 January 2020
New Opening That's All The Rage
PLAYED on board five last night for Battersea 2 against British Bangla in division two of the London League.
Nasir Rizvi (182) - Spanton (170)
'Barry Attack'
1.d4 d5 2.Nc3 e6 3.Bf4
3.e4 transposes to the French Defence. The text - first played in 1856 in Calcutta - introduces a cross between the Veresov (1.d4, 2.Nc3 and 3.Bg5) and the New London (1.d4 and 2.Bf4). One of its names is the New Veresov. I call it the Barry Attack, but this name is usually restricted for 1.d4, 2.Nc3 and 3.Bf4 against a black set-up involving an early kingside fianchetto. Another name is the Jobava-Prié Attack.
After the game, five Battersea players went to a nearby Wetherspoon. It turned out all of us, or perhaps it was just four of us, had faced 1.d4, 2.Nc3 and 3.Bf4 either that night or the night before. Clearly something is going on.
3...Bd6
The main move is 3...Nf6, as played in Moheschunder Bannerjee - John Cochrane, Calcutta 1856 (0-1, 37 moves), but the text has a better percentage score in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database.
4.e3!?
White's score leaps to an impressive 61% after this, and it can easily be seen that the text saves a tempo over 4.Bg3 and 4.Bxd6 Qxd6.
4...Bxf4
Trying to punish White's play. Black cannot necessarily delay this decision as 4...Nf6 has been met with 5.Qf3!? by Romanian international master George-Catalin Ardelean.
5.exf4 Nf6
Logical-looking is 5...Qd6!? but it is not liked, at least at first, by Stockfish10 and Komodo10, who continue 6.Qg4 Kf8 7.Qg3 with an unclear position that Stockfish10 reckons may slightly favour Black, but Komodo10 reckons favours White. As the saying has it, tests are needed.
6.Nf3 Qe7?!
Now 6...Qd6 can be met by 7.Ne5, which occurred in Richárd Rapport (2698) - Miklos Nemeth (2451), Zalakaros (Hungary) 2017 (1/2–1/2, 36 moves).
The problem with the text is that the e pawn will be pinned against the queen when a white rook lands on e1.
7.Bd3 Bd7?!
7...c5 8.dxc5 Qxc5 9.0-0 Nc6 10.Nb5 seemed slightly better for White in Igor Miladinović (2555) - Robert Markus (2625), Serbian Championship 2012, but was agreed drawn just eight moves later.
The text is what I suspect Garry Kasparov would call a half-move, ie one that is vaguely useful but does not get to the heart of the position. I was reluctant to play 7...0-0 as I feared White would castle long and launch a kingside pawn-storm.
8.0-0 0-0 9.Re1 c5 10.dxc5
10.f5 cxd4 11.fxe6 dxc3 12.exd7 Qxd7 looks fine for Black.
10...Qxc5 11.Ne5 Nc6
11...Qb4?! looks very greedy, but is maybe playable.
12.Re3!?
The engines prefer a slower build-up with, for example 12.Qd2.
12.g4!? is sharp. The engines continue 12...Qb4!? 13.Nxd7 Nxd7 14.Qf3 with a menacing-looking position for White, but the engines like Black.
12...d4!?
Forcing, but the engines prefer 12...Qb4 13.Rh3 g6 14.Qc1!? with an unclear position.
13.Ne4 Nxe4 14.Nxd7 Qd5
Not 14...Nxf2? 15.Nxc5 Nxd1 16.Rh3.
15.Bxe4 Qxd7
*****
*****
*****
*****
*****
16.Bxh7+?
Unsound.
White has a slight edge after 16.Rd3, according to the engines.
16...Kxh7 17.Rh3+ Kg8 18.Qh5 f6 19.g4 Qe8 20.Qh7+ Kf7 21.g5 fxg5 22.fxg5 Ke7!?
A good practical choice, although the engines narrowly prefer 22...e5.
23.Re1
Objectively best is 23.Qxg7+!?, but 23...Qf7 forces queens off as Black threatens f2.
23...Qf7 24.f4 Rh8 25.Qd3 Rxh3 26.Qxh3 Rf8 27.Qa3+ Kd7 28.Qb3 Kc7!?
Another practical choice.
The game finished:
29.Qxe6 Qxf4 30.g6 Rf6 31.Qe8 Qg4+ 32.Kh1 Rf2 33.Re7+ Kb6 34.Rxb7+ Kxb7 0-1
My updated Battersea statistics for 2019-20
Event*..Colour...Grade...Opponent's Grade...Result
CLL..…...B....…..168...………169...……….....W
CLL...…..B...…...168...………196...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………176...…………..L
LL....……W...…..168...…....…175...………….D
CLL...…..B...…...168...………192...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………181...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..168...………168...…………..L
EC...…….B...…..168...………175...……….….L
CLL...…...B.........170...………172...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..170...………183...…………..D
LL............W........170...…........180......……......L
LL....…….B...…..170....……...182...………….W
Overall this season for Battersea I have scored +2=4-6 for a grading performance of 162.
In season 2018-19 I scored +12=12-13 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2017-18 I scored +10=8-9 for a grading performance of 175.
*CLL: Central London League; LL: London League; EC: Eastman Cup.
Nasir Rizvi (182) - Spanton (170)
'Barry Attack'
1.d4 d5 2.Nc3 e6 3.Bf4
3.e4 transposes to the French Defence. The text - first played in 1856 in Calcutta - introduces a cross between the Veresov (1.d4, 2.Nc3 and 3.Bg5) and the New London (1.d4 and 2.Bf4). One of its names is the New Veresov. I call it the Barry Attack, but this name is usually restricted for 1.d4, 2.Nc3 and 3.Bf4 against a black set-up involving an early kingside fianchetto. Another name is the Jobava-Prié Attack.
After the game, five Battersea players went to a nearby Wetherspoon. It turned out all of us, or perhaps it was just four of us, had faced 1.d4, 2.Nc3 and 3.Bf4 either that night or the night before. Clearly something is going on.
3...Bd6
The main move is 3...Nf6, as played in Moheschunder Bannerjee - John Cochrane, Calcutta 1856 (0-1, 37 moves), but the text has a better percentage score in ChessBase's 2020 Mega database.
4.e3!?
White's score leaps to an impressive 61% after this, and it can easily be seen that the text saves a tempo over 4.Bg3 and 4.Bxd6 Qxd6.
4...Bxf4
Trying to punish White's play. Black cannot necessarily delay this decision as 4...Nf6 has been met with 5.Qf3!? by Romanian international master George-Catalin Ardelean.
5.exf4 Nf6
Logical-looking is 5...Qd6!? but it is not liked, at least at first, by Stockfish10 and Komodo10, who continue 6.Qg4 Kf8 7.Qg3 with an unclear position that Stockfish10 reckons may slightly favour Black, but Komodo10 reckons favours White. As the saying has it, tests are needed.
6.Nf3 Qe7?!
Now 6...Qd6 can be met by 7.Ne5, which occurred in Richárd Rapport (2698) - Miklos Nemeth (2451), Zalakaros (Hungary) 2017 (1/2–1/2, 36 moves).
The problem with the text is that the e pawn will be pinned against the queen when a white rook lands on e1.
7.Bd3 Bd7?!
7...c5 8.dxc5 Qxc5 9.0-0 Nc6 10.Nb5 seemed slightly better for White in Igor Miladinović (2555) - Robert Markus (2625), Serbian Championship 2012, but was agreed drawn just eight moves later.
The text is what I suspect Garry Kasparov would call a half-move, ie one that is vaguely useful but does not get to the heart of the position. I was reluctant to play 7...0-0 as I feared White would castle long and launch a kingside pawn-storm.
8.0-0 0-0 9.Re1 c5 10.dxc5
10.f5 cxd4 11.fxe6 dxc3 12.exd7 Qxd7 looks fine for Black.
10...Qxc5 11.Ne5 Nc6
11...Qb4?! looks very greedy, but is maybe playable.
12.Re3!?
The engines prefer a slower build-up with, for example 12.Qd2.
12.g4!? is sharp. The engines continue 12...Qb4!? 13.Nxd7 Nxd7 14.Qf3 with a menacing-looking position for White, but the engines like Black.
12...d4!?
Forcing, but the engines prefer 12...Qb4 13.Rh3 g6 14.Qc1!? with an unclear position.
13.Ne4 Nxe4 14.Nxd7 Qd5
Not 14...Nxf2? 15.Nxc5 Nxd1 16.Rh3.
15.Bxe4 Qxd7
![]() |
| How should White proceed? |
*****
*****
*****
*****
16.Bxh7+?
Unsound.
White has a slight edge after 16.Rd3, according to the engines.
16...Kxh7 17.Rh3+ Kg8 18.Qh5 f6 19.g4 Qe8 20.Qh7+ Kf7 21.g5 fxg5 22.fxg5 Ke7!?
A good practical choice, although the engines narrowly prefer 22...e5.
23.Re1
Objectively best is 23.Qxg7+!?, but 23...Qf7 forces queens off as Black threatens f2.
23...Qf7 24.f4 Rh8 25.Qd3 Rxh3 26.Qxh3 Rf8 27.Qa3+ Kd7 28.Qb3 Kc7!?
Another practical choice.
The game finished:
29.Qxe6 Qxf4 30.g6 Rf6 31.Qe8 Qg4+ 32.Kh1 Rf2 33.Re7+ Kb6 34.Rxb7+ Kxb7 0-1
My updated Battersea statistics for 2019-20
Event*..Colour...Grade...Opponent's Grade...Result
CLL..…...B....…..168...………169...……….....W
CLL...…..B...…...168...………196...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………176...…………..L
LL....……W...…..168...…....…175...………….D
CLL...…..B...…...168...………192...…………..D
CLL...…..W...…..168...………181...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..168...………168...…………..L
EC...…….B...…..168...………175...……….….L
CLL...…...B.........170...………172...…………..L
LL...…….W...…..170...………183...…………..D
LL............W........170...…........180......……......L
LL....…….B...…..170....……...182...………….W
Overall this season for Battersea I have scored +2=4-6 for a grading performance of 162.
In season 2018-19 I scored +12=12-13 for a grading performance of 169.
In season 2017-18 I scored +10=8-9 for a grading performance of 175.
*CLL: Central London League; LL: London League; EC: Eastman Cup.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)











