Spanton (1971) - Elías Pelegri Castello (1853)
Caro-Kann Modern Variation
1.e4 c6 2.d4 d5 3.Nc3 dxe4 4.Nxe4 Nd7
This is third in popularity in ChessBase's 2026 Mega database, behind 4...Nf6 and especially 4...Bf5.
5.Nf3 Ngf6 6.Ng3
There are 4,724 examples of the text in Mega26, just behind the 4,884 of 6.Nxf6!?, after which the main line runs 6...Nxf6 7.Bc4 Bf5 8.0-0 e6 9.c3 Be7, with a slight edge for White, according to Dragon1, although Stockfish19 is less sure.
6...e6 7.Bd3 Be7 8.0-0 0-0
*****
*****
*****
*****
White has more space in the centre, but this is of little consequence, according to the engines, presumably because Black is well-placed to get in a quick ...c5, without White being able to push on with d5. The engines reckon the game offers equal chances.
9.Re1 b6
This is second in popularity to an immediate ...c5.
10.Qe2 Bb7 11.Nf5!?
This is Dragon1's top choice. Stockfish18 suggests 11.Ng5!? or 11.Bf4.
11...c5!?
An apparent-novelty, and liked by the engines. Known moves are 11...Bb4!? and 11...exf5?!
12.Nxe7+ Qxe7 13.c3 Bxf3!?
This is the engines' top choice.
14.Qxf3 cxd4 15.cxd4 Qd6 16.Be3 Rfc8!?
The engines prefer 16...Rfd8 or 16...Nd5.
*****
*****
*****
*****
17.Rad1
The engines give 17.Ba6 Rf8!? 18.Bb7 Rad8 19.Bf4!? Qxd4 20.Bc7 Rde8 21.Rad1 Qxb2 22.Re2, when they reckon White has more than enough for two pawns, eg 22...Qb4!? 23.Bd6 Nc5 24.Red2, but the position is hardly clear.
17...Qd5 18.Qxd5 Nxd5 19.Rc1 N7f6 20.Ba6 Rd8 21.a3 Rab8 22.Bg5 Rd7 23.Rc2 h6 24.Bh4
The engines prefer 24.Be3.
24...Nh5!?
Black is at least slightly better after 24...g5!? 25.Bg3 Nf4!?, according to the engines.
25.Bb5 Rc7 26.Rec1 Rxc2 27.Rxc2 g5 28.Bg3 Nxg3
EPC offered a draw.
*****
*****
*****
*****
After ...
29.hxg3
... White has what is normally an advantageous matchup of rook and bishop against rook and knight. But here that is balanced by Black having fewer pawn islands, and in particular not having an isolani. The engines reckon the position is equal, albeit marginally preferring Black.
29...Rd8 30.Ba6 Rd7!? 31.Rc8+ Kg7 32.Bb5 Rc7 33.Rxc7 Nxc7
*****
*****
*****
*****
White's extra pawn island, and a lack of meaningful targets for the bishop, mean Black is slightly better, according to Dragon1, although Stockfish19 disagrees.
34.Bc6 f5!? 35.Kf1 Kf6 36.f4?!
Played to prevent ...e5, but probably a mistake.
36...Ke7 37.Ke2 Kd6 38.Bb7 Nd5
This is Dragon1's recommendation for quite some time, but Stockfish19 much prefers 38...g4!?, claiming Black is winning. Dragon1 comes to agree 38...g4!? is best, but is far less sure how strong it is.
After 38...g4!?, best play may run 39.Ke3 a5 40.Kd3 Ne8!? 41.Bc8 Nf6 42.Ke3 Nh5 43.Kf2 Kd5 44.b3 Kd6!? 45.Bb7 Nf6 46.Ke3, when the engines are enthusiastic about Black's chances, but it is not clear how Black makes progress.
39.Kf3?
Much better, according to the engines, are 39.Bxd5 and 39.fxg5!?
39...a5
The engines agree Black is winning after 39...g4+!? and 39...Nf6, but especially after the former.
*****
*****
*****
*****
40.fxg5! hxg5 41.g4!?
Preventing a favourable ...g4 seems to be the key to White's salvation.
41...Nf6 42.gxf5 exf5 43.g3 Kc7 44.Ba6 Kd6 45.Bc8 Kd5 46.Ke3?!
This may be OK, but a simpler way to a halfpoint is 46.Bxf5.
46...Ng4+ 47.Kf3!?
Dragon1 reckons this loses, but Stockfish19 disagrees. However, their evaluations fluctuate, and they agree the text is better than 47.Kd3? Nf2+. but possibly not as good as 47.Kd2!?
47...Kxd4 48.Bxf5 Ne5+ 49.Ke2 Nc4 50.b4 Nxa3 51.bxa5 bxa5
*****
*****
*****
*****
52.Kf3?
Eight moves draw, according to the Syzygy endgame tablebase, including 52.Bd7 and 52.Kd2, but not the text.
*****
*****
*****
*****
52...Nc4?
52...a4!? and 52...Nb5!? win, eg 52...Nb5!? 53.Kg4 a4 54.Bb1 a3 55.Kxg5 Kc3!? 56.Ba2 Kb2 57.Bf7 Nd4 58.Kf4 Nb3 etc.
*****
*****
*****
*****
53.Bc2!
An only-move. Dragon1 reckons is inadequate, but it draws, as Stockfish19 quickly realises. Note that the similarly motivated 53.Bd7?? loses trivially to 53...Ne5+.
53...Ne5+
Dragon1's other 'winning' move, 53...Nb2, fails to 54.Kg4.
54.Ke2 Nc4 55.Kf3
Also drawing is 55.Ba4.
55...Ne3 56.Ba4 ½–½















